Logo Passei Direto
Buscar

A Platform for Citizen Cooperation during the COVID-19 Pandemic in RN

User badge image

Enviado por Douglas Teste Um em

páginas com resultados encontrados.
páginas com resultados encontrados.
left-side-bubbles-backgroundright-side-bubbles-background

Crie sua conta grátis para liberar esse material. 🤩

Já tem uma conta?

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

left-side-bubbles-backgroundright-side-bubbles-background

Crie sua conta grátis para liberar esse material. 🤩

Já tem uma conta?

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

left-side-bubbles-backgroundright-side-bubbles-background

Crie sua conta grátis para liberar esse material. 🤩

Já tem uma conta?

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

left-side-bubbles-backgroundright-side-bubbles-background

Crie sua conta grátis para liberar esse material. 🤩

Já tem uma conta?

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

left-side-bubbles-backgroundright-side-bubbles-background

Crie sua conta grátis para liberar esse material. 🤩

Já tem uma conta?

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

left-side-bubbles-backgroundright-side-bubbles-background

Crie sua conta grátis para liberar esse material. 🤩

Já tem uma conta?

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

left-side-bubbles-backgroundright-side-bubbles-background

Crie sua conta grátis para liberar esse material. 🤩

Já tem uma conta?

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

left-side-bubbles-backgroundright-side-bubbles-background

Crie sua conta grátis para liberar esse material. 🤩

Já tem uma conta?

Ao continuar, você aceita os Termos de Uso e Política de Privacidade

Prévia do material em texto

4�CYN`S\^Z� S\^�6V`VfR[� 6\\]R^N`V\[� Qa^V[T� `UR�
6BI<7$(0� CN[QRZVP� V[�EA#� 5^NfVY
7 ST[b^]� ST� 7 aPdY^#� ?baPT[� = PaRXP� D T[X^� 9PRW^#� B^dXb� 7 acWda� S^� D PbRX\ T]c^#
>[ISPJ�;PUPYZX_� V M�ZOL� AZHZL� V M�@PV� 6XHUKL� KV�<VXZL� : ^dV[Pb� H ^[X\ #� @^bT� 7 [Tg� ST� C TSTXa^b#
DPcP[#� 8aPiX[� IPaP� IP]cP]P#� 7 [Tg� IP]Sa^� FPXeP#� C PcWXPb� BX\ P#
PST[b^]%SXPb6\_a]%\_%Qa#� XbaPT[%VPaRXP6\_a]%\_%Qa� JWdP]]h� H P\ ^b#� A [TXcXP]]T� C PRTS^#� @^aVT� FTaTXaP#
@T\ X\ P� D PbRX\ T]c^#� BTP]Sa^� C ^]cTXa^#
C PaXP]T� <Ta]P]STb#� D PcP]PT[� <Ta]P]STb#� < aTSTaXR^� B^_Tb�
3PNPZHS�;LZXVWVSPY� 8UYZPZ[ZL�
5LKLXHS�CUP\LXYPZ_� V M�@PV� 6XHUKL� KV�<VXZL�
DPcP[#� 8aPiX[
]T[X^RPRW^6SX\P_%dU\%Qa#� [^dXbPacWda6dUa]%TSd%Qa#�
S^dV[Pba^[X\6V\PX[%R^\#�Y%P[Tg%\TSTXa^b6V\PX[%R^\#�
bPaPP%QTPcaXii6V\PX[%R^\#� P%b%_PXeP0/6V\PX[%R^\#�
\PcWXPb%\^aPXb.6V\PX[%R^\#� cWdP]]haP\^b\b6V\PX[%R^\#�
Z[ThcXP]]T\PRTS^6V\PX[%R^\#�Y^aVT_TaTXaPbQ6V\PX[%R^\#�
YT\X\P],*6V\PX[%R^\#� [TP]Sa^%[b\^6V\PX[%R^\#�
\PaXP]TUT[Xg,06V\PX[%R^\#� ]PcP]$UTa]P]STb(6W^c\PX[%R^\#�
UaTS%[^_Tb6V\PX[%R^\
�#*+)"$+jGUR� P\^\[NbV^a_� ]N[QRZVP� PUNYYR[TRQ� _ZN^`� PV`VR_�
`\� R[P\a^NTR� PV`VfR[_� `\cN^Q_� `UR� _\PVNY� QV_`N[PR#� N_� cRYY� N_� `\�
\]`VZVfR� URNY`U� N[Q� ]\YVPV[T� ^R_\a^PR_� NYY\PN`V\[%� @\OVYR� N]]_�
UNbR� ]YNeRQ� N[� a[]^RPRQR[`RQ� ^\YR� Qa^V[T� `UV_� ]N[QRZVP� `\�
R[NOYR� PV`VfR[_� `\� ]N^`VPV]N`R� N[Q� V[`R^NP`� cV`U� _\PVNY� V__aR_�
cUVYR� ^NV_V[T� P\[PR^[_� NO\a`� ]^VbNPe� N[Q� _a^bRVYYN[PR%� <[� N�
]N^`[R^_UV]� \S� `UR� AN`NY� _ZN^`� PV`e� V[V`VN`VbR� \S� `UR� a[VbR^_V`e�
N[Q� `UR� ]aOYVP� ZV[V_`^e#� cR� QR]Y\eRQ� `UR� kG\� QR� BYU\l� GQB!�
]YN`S\^Z� S\^� V[`RT^N`V[T� QVSSR^R[`� _RP`\^_� \S� _\PVR`e� NTNV[_`�
P\^\[NbV^a_� _]^RNQV[T� V[� `UR� _`N`R� \S� EA#� 5^NfVY%� <[� YR__� `UN[�
S\a^� Z\[`U_#� GQB� ^RNPURQ� Z\^R� `UN[� )'#'''� a_R^_� cV`U� _RbR^NY�
a_R^� ^\YR_#� Sa[P`V\[NYV`VR_� N[Q� N� _`^VP`Ye� QRSV[RQ� ]^VbNPe� ]\YVPe%�
?\PN`V\[�QN`N�NYY\c_�GQB�`\�[\`VSe�a_R^_�cUR[�`URe�UNbR�]\__VOYR�
_a_]VPV\a_�P\[`NP`�cV`U�N[� V[SRP`RQ�]R^_\[�\^�UNbR� T\[R� `U^\aTU�
bV^a_� U\`� f\[R_%� GUR� ]YN`S\^Z� NY_\� URY]_� PV`e� URNY`U� \SSVPVNY_� `\�
_RYRP`�]R\]YR�S\^� V[SRP`V\a_�`R_`V[T#�NPP\^QV[T�`\�a_R^�V[S\^ZN`V\[�
\[� _eZ]`\Z_#� P\Z\^OVQ� QV_RN_R_#� P\[`NP`� cV`U� V[SRP`RQ� ]R\]YR#�
^V_X� _`N`a_� N[Q� DE� URNY`U� P\QR%� Ba^� V[`RT^N`V\[� cV`U� ]^VbN`R�
V[_`V`a`V\[_� R[NOYR_� RZ]Y\eR^_� `\� X[\c� cUVPU� RZ]Y\eRR_� UNbR�
`R_`RQ� ]\_V`VbR� `\� ]^\`RP`� c\^X� R[bV^\[ZR[`_%� JR� QV_Pa__� `UR�
]N^`[R^_UV]_� V[b\YbRQ� cV`U� GQBm_� QR]Y\eZR[`� N[Q� P\Z]N^R� \a^�
P\[`Rd`� cV`U� ^RYN`RQ� N]]_� N^\a[Q� `UR� c\^YQ#� _aTTR_`V[T� `UN`�
]aOYVP� _P^a`V[e#� T\bR^[ZR[`� V[bR_`ZR[`_� N[Q� V[`RT^N`V\[� cV`U�
NP`VbR� N]]YVPN`V\[_� V[� `UR� PV`e� N^R� R__R[`VNY� `\� NPUVRbV[T� ZN__VbR�
a_R%� 9a^`UR^#� cR� RbNYaN`R� `UR� SRRQONPX� \S� NP`VbR� a_R^_� A� 2�
(.,!#�N[NYefV[T�`UR�]\_V`VbR�]\V[`_�N[Q�NQbV_V[T�VZ]^\bRZR[`_�S\^�
Sa`a^R� c\^X� \[� ]N^`VPV]N`\^e� N]]YVPN`V\[_� Qa^V[T� N[� R]VQRZVP%
 (%&,�!&)'*j_ZN^`�PV`VR_#�]N[QRZVP#�PV`VfR[_#�P\[`NP`�`^NPV[T#�
V[SRP`V\a_� `R_`V[T%�<%
?%� ?AGEB7H6G<BA
8TU^aT� cWT� R^a^]PeXadb� _P]ST\XR#� T_XST\XRb� WPeT� cPZT]�
_[PRT�X]�P�\dRW�[Tbb� V[^QP[XiTS�R^]cTgc�X]�cTa\b� ^U�cTRW]^[^V$
XRP[� dQX`dXch%� JWT� b_aTPS� ^U� \^QX[T� P__b� fPb� bcX[[� T\TaVX]V�
fWT]� >(D(� X]U[dT]iP� b_aTPS� cWa^dVW^dc� cWT� f^a[S� X]� )''0%�
D^fPSPhb#�\^QX[T�X]cTa]Tc�caPUUXR�bXV]XUXRP]c[h� bda_PbbTS�STbZ$
c^_b� Pc�cWT� bP\T�cX\T�cWPc�b\Pac�RXcXTb� WPeT�QTT]� ST\P]STS�c^�
dbT� ?9J� X]UaPbcadRcdaT� U^a� X\_a^eX]V� _T^_[T b� `dP[Xch� ^U�[XUT#�
U^a�TgP\_[T#�cWa^dVW�_PacXRX_Pc^ah�V^eTa]P]RT�N(O%�JWaTT�U^d]$
SPcX^]b� U^a� bdRW� _PacXRX_Pc^ah� \^ST[� PaT� cTRW]^[^Vh#� _T^_[T�
P]S� X]bcXcdcX^]b� N)O%� :daX]V� cWT� 9EL?:$(0� _P]ST\XR#� bTeTaP[�
RWP[[T]VTb� T\TaVTS�c^�X]bcXVPcT�_PacXRX_Pc^ah�b^[dcX^]b�cWPc�PaT�
SaXeT]� Qh� cWTbT� U^d]SPcX^]b%� JWdb� fT� R[PX\� b\Pac� RXcXTb� c^�
P]bfTa1� W^f� cTRW]^[^Vh� RP]� T]PQ[T� RXcXiT]b� c^� R^[[PQ^aPcT�
fXcW� _dQ[XR� PVT]cb� P]S#� \^bc� X\_^acP]c[h#� X]bcXcdcX^]b�
c^� R^[[PQ^aPcT� fXcW� RXcXiT]b� SdaX]V� P]� T_XST\XR5� 7b� P]�
TgP\_[T� ^U� TPa[h� \^QX[T� P__� TUU^acb� cWPc� P__TPaTS� ^]� cWXb�
_TaX^S#� lSXVXcP[� R^]cPRc� caPRX]Vm� WPb� QTT]� X\_[T\T]cTS� dbX]V�
\^QX[T� P__b� X]� bTeTaP[� STeT[^_TS� R^d]caXTb� c^� X]bcP]c[h� P[Tac�
dbTab� fW^� WPeT� WPS� R^]cPRc� fXcW� _T^_[T� cTbcTS� fXcW� 9EL?:$�
(0%� IcdSXTb� WPeT�bdVVTbcTS�cWPc�cWXb�P__a^PRW�RP]� bXV]XUXRP]c[h�
aTSdRT� cWT� eXadbn� b_aTPS� eXadb� N*O%
<dacWTa#� cWT� R^a^]PeXadb� _P]ST\XR� RWP[[T]VTS� b\Pac� RXcXTb�
c^� bcX\d[PcT� b^RXP[� SXbcP]RX]V#� Pb� fT[[� Pb� WTP[cW� P]S� _^[XRX]V�
aTb^daRT� P[[^RPcX^]%� IX]RT� cWT� TR^]^\XR� SXbcaTbb� WPb� U^aRTS�
V^eTa]\T]cb� c^� cPZT� daVT]c� \TPbdaTb� P]S� b_T]S� \dRW� \^aT�
cWP]� dbdP[#� X]U^a\PcX^]� PQ^dc� b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]� [TeT[#� eXadb� W^c�
i^]Tb#� P]S� PVV[^\TaPcX^]� W^c� b_^cb� RP]� QT� RadRXP[� U^a� P]�
X]cTVaPcTS� STRXbX^]� \PZX]V� SdaX]V� P]� T_XST\XR%� JWTaTU^aT#�
RXcXiT]b� R^^_TaPcX^]� RP]� QT� eXcP[� c^� T]PQ[T� bdRW� P]� X]U^a\P$
cX^]� ]Tcf^aZ#� U^a� TgP\_[T� fXcW� [^RPcX^]$QPbTS� X]cTaPRcX^]b%�
7[cW^dVW� cWTaT� Xb� P]� ^_T]� SXbRdbbX^]� PQ^dc� _aXePRh� P]S
© IEEE 2020. This article is free to access and download, along with rights for full text and data mining, re-use and 
analysis
Authorized licensed use limited to: IEEE Xplore. Downloaded on March 04,2021 at 13:22:49 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply. 
bdaeTX[[P]RT� X]� RT]caP[XiTS� bhbcT\b� N+O#� fT� fX[[� PaVdT� cWPc�cWT�
_T^_[Tnb� R^]caXQdcX^]#� aT_^acX]V� PVV[^\TaPcX^]b� W^c� b_^cb� P]S�
cT\_^aPaX[h� bWPaX]V� cWTXa� [^RPcX^]� SPcP� fXcW� aXV^a^db� TcWXRP[�
R^\_[XP]RT#� RP]� bd__^ac� QTccTa� \P]PVT\T]c� ^U� cWT� RXchnb�
aTb^daRTb%� E]� cWT� ^cWTa� WP]S#� SPcP�_a^cTRcX^]� VdXST[X]Tb� \dbc�
QT� bcaXRc[h� STUX]TS#� U^[[^fTS� P]S� \^]Xc^aTS� Qh� X]bcXcdcX^]b� ^U�
[TVP[�aT_aTbT]cPcX^]�^U�cWT�_T^_[T#� U^a�TgP\_[T�Qh�_a^bTRdc^ab%�
JWT]#� [^RP[� PdcW^aXcXTb� \dbc� _dc� cWT� RXcXiT]b� X]� cWT� [^^_#� Qh�
PccT]SX]V� cWTXa� ST]d]RXPcX^]b� P]S� VXeX]V� QPRZ� X]U^a\PcX^]� ^]�
X]UTRcX^db� aXbZb� [TeT[b� cWTh� PaT� Tg_^bTS� c^� VXeT]� cWT� [^RPcX^]�
bWPaTS%� 7[b^#� P�SXeTabT�bTc�^U�Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb� bcX\d[PcT�SXUUTaT]c�
bTRc^ab� ^U�b^RXTch� c^fPaSb� \^aT� T]VPVT\T]c%
?]� cWXb� f^aZ#� fT� R^]bXSTa� Ud]SP\T]cP[� aT`dXaT\T]cb� U^a� P�
b\Pac� RXch� c^� X]cTaPRc� fXcW� RXcXiT]b� c^fPaSb� b^RXP[� SXbcP]RT�
\TPbdaTb� P]S� QTccTa� _dQ[XR� bTaeXRTb� P[[^RPcX^]� SdaX]V� P]�
T_XST\XR%� Eda� b^[dcX^]� U^a� cWTbT� aT`dXaT\T]cb� Xb� cWT� JSE �
_[PcU^a\#�ad]]X]V�X]�HX^�=aP]ST�S^�D^acT#� P�]^acWTPbcTa]�bcPcT�
^U�8aPiX[%�JWT�_[PcU^a\�R^]bXbcb�^U�P�\^QX[T�P__[XRPcX^]#� P�fTQ�
\^Sd[T� P]S� P�SPbWQ^PaS� cWPc#� fWXRW� X]� [Tbb� cWP]� U^da�\^]cWb�
PRWXTeTS�\^aT�cWP]� )'#'''� dbTab%� 9XcXiT]b#� _aXePcT� X]bcXcdcX^]b�
P]S�_dQ[XR�PVT]cb�WPeT�SXbcX]Rc�a^[Tb�X]�cWT�P__[XRPcX^]#� b^�cWTh�
RP]� R^^_TaPcT� c^VTcWTa� fXcW� cWT� Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb� PePX[PQ[T%� JWT�
_[PcU^a\�fPb�STeT[^_TS�?]�P�_Pac]TabWX_�^U�cWT�DPcP[�b\Pac�RXch�
X]XcXPcXeT�^U�cWT� d]XeTabXch� P]S�cWT�_dQ[XR�\X]Xbcah#� fWXRW� P[b^�
R^[[PQ^aPcTS�fXcW�P�R[TPa[h� P]S�bcaXRc[h�STUX]TS�SPcP�_a^cTRcX^]�
_^[XRh%
8TbXSTb�cWT�ST]d]RXPcX^]b�P]S�b^RXP[�Xb^[PcX^]�[TeT[�\^]Xc^a$
X]V#�cWT�_[PcU^a\�[TeTaPVTb�cf^�^cWTa�X\_^acP]c�Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb%�
<Xabc#� fT� P__a^PRW� SXVXcP[� R^]cPRc� caPRX]V� fXcW� RT]caP[XiTS�
\TcW^S^[^Vh�QPbTS�^]�=FI� P[b^�R^]bXSTaX]V�dbTa�R^]cPRc�fXcW�
eXadb�W^c�i^]Tb%�7[cW^dVW�cWXb�P__a^PRW�RP]�[TPS�c^�P�aT[PcXeT[h�
WXVW�aPcT�^U�UP[bT�_^bXcXeTb#� fT�SXbRdbb� fXcW�dbTa�UTTSQPRZ�cWPc�
cWT� _P]XR� bT]bPcX^]� VT]TaPcTS�Qh� ^da� R^]cPRc�]^cXUXRPcX^]� \Ph�
]^c� QT� c^^� WXVW� Pb� Xc� \Ph� QT� Tg_TRc%� ITR^]S#� cWT� _[PcU^a\�
T]PQ[Tb� P� bT[TRcXeT� X]UTRcX^db� cTbcX]V� Ud]RcX^]P[Xch� U^a� WTP[cW�
PdcW^aXcXTb� c^� bRWTSd[T� _PcXT]cb� QPbTS� ^]� bTeTaP[� \TcaXRb#� T%V%�
PVT#� aTRT]c� R^]cPRc� ]^cXUXRPcX^]#� R^\^aQXS� SXbTPbTb� !X%T%� bdQ$
PSYPRT]c� SXbTPbTb#� \PX][h� SXPQTcTb#� RPaSX^ePbRd[Pa� ^a� aTb_XaP$
c^ah"%� FdQ[XR� WTP[cW� PVT]cb� RP]�bT]S� X]eXcPcX^]b� c^� cWT� dbTab#�
cWPc�RP]�PRRT_c#� STR[X]T�^a�aTbRWTSd[T�cWT�UaTT�cTbc%� JTbc�aTbd[cb�
RP]� QT� X\\TSXPcT[h� _a^RTbbTS� c^� X]U^a\� _aXePcT� X]bcXcdcX^]b�
fWTcWTa� P]� T\_[^hTT� fPb� _^bXcXeT#� XU�cWT� dbTa� PVaTTb%� FaXePcT�
X]bcXcdcX^]b� RP]� QT� QT]TUXcTS� Qh� Xb^[PcX]V� f^aZTab� cT\_^aPaX[h�
P]S� ]TV^cXPcT� fXcW� cWT� V^eTa]\T]c� c^fPaSb� P� bPUT� `dPaP]cX]T�
U[TgXQX[XiPcX^]%
7[cW^dVW� cWT� aT`dXaT\T]cb� U^a� RXcXiT]� R^^_TaPcX^]� SdaX]V�
cWT�_P]ST\XR�fT�[Xbc�Xb�Qh�]^�\TP]b�R^\_[TcT#�Xc�RP]�QT�dbTS�Pb�
P�_aT[X\X]Pah� VdXST� U^a� TeP[dPcX^]%� MT� SXbRdbb� dbTa� UTTSQPRZ�
^]� b^\T� ^U�cWT� _a^_^bTS�aT`dXaT\T]cb#� PX\X]V� c^� Tg_[^aT� cWT�
X\_PRc� ^U� cWT� _[PcU^a\� X]� X\_a^eX]V� RXcXiT]� R^^_TaPcX^]%� MT�
bdaeThTS� PRcXeT� dbTab� !D� 3� (.,"� PQ^dc� cWTXa� ^_X]X^]b� ^]� W^f�
cWT� JSE� WPb� Ud[UX[[TS� Xcb� a^[T� SdaX]V� cWT� _P]ST\XR%� MT� PbZTS�
PQ^dc� aXbZ� [TeT[b� caP]b_PaT]Rh#� _P]XR� bT]bPcX^]� Ua^\� R^]cPRc�
caPRX]V�]^cXUXRPcX^]#� RdaaT]c�[X\XcPcX^]b� ^U�cWT�_[PcU^a\#� P\^]V�
^cWTab� Pb_TRcb%� JWT� bdaeTh� [TeTaPVTS� \PcTaXP[� U^a� SXbRdbbX]V�
X\_a^eT\T]cb� P]S� U^a� PSeXbX]V� UdcdaT� f^aZ�fWT]� X\_[T\T]c$
X]V� RXcXiT]� R^^_TaPcX^]� P__b� SdaX]V� P]� T_XST\XR%
JWXb� _P_Ta� Xb� ^aVP]XiTS� Pb� U^[[^fb%� ?]� ITRcX^]� ??#� fT�
STbRaXQT� X]� fWXRW� X]bcXcdcX^]P[� R^]cTgc� JSE� fPb� STeT[^_TS�
P]S� fWPc� _aXePRh� VdXST[X]Tb� fTaT� TbcPQ[XbWTS%� ?]� ITRcX^]� ???#�
fT� [Xbc� aT`dXaT\T]cb� c^� bd__^ac� RXcXiT]� R^^_TaPcX^]� SdaX]V�
cWT� _P]ST\XR%� ITRcX^]� ?L� STbRaXQTb� cWT� _[PcU^a\� aTVPaSX]V�
Xcb� PaRWXcTRcdaT#� dbTa� a^[Tb� P]S� P__a^PRWTb� dbTS#� STcPX[X]V�
cWT� P__[XRPcX^]� P]S� _PacXRd[Pa� Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb%� ?]� ITRcX^]� L#�
fT� SXbRdbb� JSE� _Pac]TabWX_b#� R^\_PaXb^]� fXcW� aT[PcTS� P__b�
Pa^d]S� cWT� f^a[S#� P]S� SXbRdbb� dbTa� UTTSQPRZ� ^]� cWT� \PX]�
Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb%� <X]P[[h#� fT� _a^eXST� R^]R[dSX]V� aT\PaZb� X]�
ITRcX^]� L?%
??%� ; G ; <6 4 ? � 6 B A F < 7 8 E 4 G <B A F
JWT� JSE� _[PcU^a\� fPb� STeT[^_TS� fXcWX]� cWT� DPcP[� b\Pac�
RXch� X]XcXPcXeT� N,O#� X]� _Pac]TabWX_� QTcfTT]� cWT� d]XeTabXch� P]S�
cWT� [^RP[� _dQ[XR� \X]Xbcah� !CFHD"#� _a^eXSX]V� bTaeXRTb� U^a� cWT�
RXcXiT]b� ^U� P[[� RXcXTb� ^U� cWT� 8aPiX[XP]� bcPcT� ^U� HX^� =aP]ST� S^�
D^acT� !HD"%� E]T� ^U� ^da� _aX\Pah� R^]RTa]b� fWT]� STeT[^_X]V�
cWT� _[PcU^a\� fPb� ]^c� c^� X\_[T\T]c� P� bdaeTX[[P]RT� X]bcad\T]c�
U^a� b^RXP[� R^]ca^[�]TXcWTa�c^�aTSdRT�X]SXeXSdP[�UaTTS^\%� FdQ[XR�
\X]XbcaXTb� X]� 8aPiX[� WPb� cWT� aTb_^]bXQX[Xch� ^U� \^]Xc^aX]V� P]S�
aT_^acX]V� X[[TVP[� V^eTa]\T]c� PRcX^]b#� P]S� PaT� X]ST_T]ST]c� X]$
bcXcdcX^]b�cWPc�[TeTaPVT�RXcXiT]bn� R^]RTa]b%� 7[cW^dVW�fT�R^[[TRc�
RXcXiT]b� bT]bXQ[T�SPcP#�CFHD�WPb�TbcPQ[XbWTS�P�_aXePRh�_^[XRh(�
R[TPa[h� bcPcX]V� cWPc�cWT� ^][h� X]bcXcdcX^]� fXcWX]� cWT� V^eTa]\T]c�
cWPc�fX[[�WPeT�PRRTbb� c^�cWT�SPcP�Xb� cWT�bcPcT�WTP[cW�ST_Pac\T]c#�
fWXRW� WPb� cWT� bP\T� aTb_^]bXQX[Xch� c^� _a^cTRc� _Tab^]P[� SPcP�
TeT]cdP[[h� dbTS%
CFHD� Tg_[XRXc[h� d]STacPZTb� ]^c� c^� dbT� cWT� SPcP� X]� P]h�
]Tf#� UX[TS� ^a� ^]V^X]V� [TVP[�_a^RTTSX]Vb#� Pb� fT[[� Pb� c^� STbca^h�
bT]bXcXeT� SPcP� PUcTa� cWT� T]S� ^U� cWT� _P]ST\XR%� DTXcWTa� cWT�
V^eTa]\T]c� ^UUXRT#� ]^a� _^[XRT#� ]^a� _aXePcT� X]bcXcdcX^]b� fX[[� QT�
PQ[T� c^� dbT� SPcP� _a^cTRcTS� Qh� cWT� _aXePRh� _^[XRh� TgcTa]P[[h%�
?]bcTPS#� PVVaTVPcT� X]U^a\PcX^]� fX[[� QT� PePX[PQ[T� c^� bd__^ac�
X\\TSXPcT� STRXbX^]� \PZX]V� P]S�aTb^daRT� P[[^RPcX^]%
???%� F? 4 G 9 B E @ � E 8 D H <E 8 @ 8 A G F
?]� cWT� R^]cTgc� ^U� P� b\Pac� RXch#� fT� T]eXbX^]� bXg� \PX]�
aT`dXaT\T]cb� c^� T]PQ[T� _dQ[XR� X]cTaPRcX^]b� QTcfTT]� RXcXiT]b#�
_aXePcT�X]bcXcdcX^]b�P]S�_dQ[XR�PdcW^aXcXTb� SdaX]V�cWT�_P]ST\XR%
% � >[ISPJ� KLU[UJPHZPVUY.� RXcXiT]b� \dbc� QT� PQ[T� c^� XST]cXUh�
P]S� P[Tac� [^RP[� PdcW^aXcXTb� PQ^dc� ePaX^db� _a^Q[T\b� X]� cWT� RXch#�
U^a�TgP\_[T#�_[PRTb� fXcW�P�WXVW�R^]RT]caPcX^]�^U�_T^_[T%� JWTh�
fX[[� fPXc� U^a� cWTXa� R^\_[PX]cb� c^� QT� P]bfTaTS#� b^� cWT� _dQ[XR�
PdcW^aXcXTb� \dbc� aTRTXeT� cWTbT� R^\_[PX]cb%� JWT� _dQ[XR� PVT]c�
\dbc� QT� P[[^fTS� c^� RWP]VT� cWT� bcPcdb� ^U� cWT� ST\P]S� P]S� cWT�
RXcXiT]� c^� \^]Xc^a� cWT� _a^VaTbb%� B^RP[� PdcW^aXcXTb� bW^d[S� P[b^�
QT� PQ[T� c^� U^afPaS� cWT\� c^� P]^cWTa�_dQ[XR� PVT]c� XU�]TTSTS%
& � ;VUPZVXPUN� JP\PJ� LUNHNLTLUZ.� QTbXSTb� WTP[cW� P]S�_^[XR$
X]V� PdcW^aXcXTb#� ^cWTa� _dQ[XR� PVT]cb� RP]� X\_a^eT� STRXbX^]$
\PZX]V� Qh� caPRZX]V� RXeXR� T]VPVT\T]c� ePaXPQ[Tb%� <^a� TgP\_[T#�
Xc� \dbc� T]PQ[T� c^� _a^eXST� R^]bcP]c[h� d_SPcTS� eXbdP[XiPcX^]b�
PQ^dc�ST]d]RXPcX^]b� W^c� b_^cb#� b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]�[TeT[� P]S� ^cWTa
(�U``]_1&&`\QR\YU\%Z]^[%Z]%O^&]^VbNPVQNQR%]QS
Authorized licensed use limited to: IEEE Xplore. Downloaded on March 04,2021 at 13:22:49 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply. 
PePX[PQ[T� X]U^a\PcX^]� R^]RTa]X]V� cWT� RXcXiT]� X]e^[eT\T]c� X]�
R^]cPX]X]V� cWT� eXadb%
' � 3PNPZHS�JVUZHJZ�ZXHJPUN.� M>E� STbRaXQTb� R^]cPRc� caPRX]V�
X]�cWaTT� bcT_b� N-O1� !X"� XST]cXUhX]V� cWT� R^]cPRcb� ^U�cWT� R^]UXa\TS�
_^bXcXeT#� !XX"� [XbcX]V� cWT� R^]cPRcb#� X]U^a\X]V� cWT\� ^U� _^bbXQ[T�
R^]cPRc� fXcW� P]� X]UTRcTS� _Tab^]� P]S� !XXX"� P� U^[[^f$d_� _a^RTbb%�
=XeT]� cWT� aPcT� Pc� fWXRW� cWT� eXadb� b_aTPSb#� \P]dP[� R^]cPRc�
caPRX]V� RP]� T]S� d_� QTX]V� eTah� Tg_T]bXeT#� ]^c� b^� bRP[PQ[T� P]S�
\^aT� _a^]T� c^� ]^cXUh� c^^� b[^f[h� c^� R^]cPX]� eXadb� b_aTPSX]V
N*O%� JWT� bhbcT\� bW^d[S� Pdc^\PcT� cWXb� _a^RTbb� X]� ^aSTa� c^�
]^cXUh� R^]cPRcb� fWT]� cWTh� WP__T]� ^a� Pb� b^^]� Pb� _^bbXQ[T%�
7RR^aSX]V�c^� N+O#� bTeTaP[�Pb_TRcb�\Ph�X]U[dT]RT�R^]cPRc�caPRX]V�
P__[XRPcX^]b1
j� DPcdaT� ^U�cWT� \^ST[1� 9T]caP[XiTS� ^a� STRT]caP[XiTS%
j� JTRW]X`dT� T\_[^hTS1� 8[dTc^^cW� ^a� =FI%
j� FaXePRh1� <a^\� b]^^_Tab#� ^cWTa�dbTab� P]S� cWT� V^eTa]\T]c%
j� 7SeTabPaXP[� \^ST[1� IhbcT\� QTWPeX^a� PVPX]bc� PccPRZTab%
j� IRP[PQX[Xch1� IhbcT\� QTWPeX^a� fXcW� X]RaTPbX]V� f^aZ[^PSb%
( � ALSLJZP\L� PUMLJZPV[Y� ZLYZPUN.� VXeT]� cWT� ST\P]S� U^a� RXcXTb�
c^� aT^_T]� QdbX]TbbTb#� WTP[cW� PdcW^aXcXTb� \dbc� bTTZ� P]� TUUXRXT]c�
cTbcX]V� _a^RTbb� c^� X]RaTPbT� R^eTaPVT� ^U� _T^_[T� [XZT[h� c^� QT�
X]UTRcTS%� JWT� _[PcU^a\� \dbc� bd__^ac� WTP[cW� PdcW^aXcXTb� fXcW�
c^^[b�c^�UX[cTa�dbTab�cWPc�WPeT�bdb_TRc�bh\_c^\b#�aT[PcTS�R^\^a$
QXSXcXTb� !T%V%� SXPQTcTb� RPaSX^ePbRd[Pa� ^a� aTb_XaPc^ah� SXbTPbT"#�
^a� cW^bT� fW^� WPeT� eXbXcTS� eXadb� W^c� i^]Tb#� PRR^aSX]V� c^�
^da� R^]cPRc� caPRX]V� bhbcT\%� FTab^]P[� SPcP� \dbc� QT� PRRTbbTS�
TgR[dbXeT[h�Qh�cWT�WTP[cW�PdcW^aXcXTb� P]S�U^a�P�aTbcaXRcTS�_TaX^S�
^U�cX\T%� 7[b^#� PUcTa� WTP[cW� PVT]cb� bRWTSd[T� cTbcb� fXcW� bT[TRcTS�
dbTab#� cWT� _[PcU^a\� \dbc� ]^cXUh� cWT� X]eXcPcX^]� P]S� [Tc� cWT� dbTa�
PRRT_c� ^a� STR[X]T%� ?]� PRRT_cTS� X]eXcPcX^]b#� cWT� X]SXRPcTS� cX\T�
bW^d[S� QT� aTbTaeTS%
) � 8UZLNXHZPVU� ]PZO� WXP\HZL� PUYZPZ[ZPVUY.� aT^_T]X]V� [^RP[�
QdbX]TbbTb� ]TTSb� _[P]]X]V� X]� P� bPUT� P]S� R^^aSX]PcTS� \P]]Ta%�
JWdb� _aXePcT� X]bcXcdcX^]b� \dbc�WPeT� \TP]b� c^� X]cTaPRc� fXcW� cWT�
bhbcT\%� <^a� TgP\_[T#� cWT� _[PcU^a\� \dbc�QT� PQ[T� c^� bW^f� TPRW�
R^\_P]h� cWPc� T\_[^hTTb� WPeT� cTbcTS� _^bXcXeT� c^� _a^cTRc� cWT�
aTbc� ^U� cWTXa� T\_[^hTTb� P]S� _aTeT]c� cWT� f^aZ� T]eXa^]\T]c�
Ua^\� QTX]V� P]� PVVaPePcX]V� UPRc^a� X]� caP]b\XccX]V� cWT� eXadb%�
FaXePcT� X]bcXcdcX^]b� X]cTaPRcX]V� fXcW� cWT� _[PcU^a\� Xb� X\_^acP]c�
c^� XST]cXUh� fWXRW� QdbX]Tbb� PaT� \^aT� bPUT� c^� ^_T]� P]S� fWXRW�
\Ph� ]TTS� aTbcaXRcX^]b%
* � 8UZLNXHZPVU� ]PZO� ZOPXK"WHXZ_� JPZ_� HWWY.� b^\T� RXcXTb� WPeT�
^]T�^a�\^aT�\^QX[T�P__b�cWPc�Xb�R^\\^][h�dbTS�Qh�cWT�_T^_[T#�
T%V%� P__�U^a�caP]b_^acPcX^]%� DTf� P__b� \dbc�QT� PQ[T�c^� X]cTVaPcT�
fXcW�cWT\�c^�PRWXTeT�Qa^PSTa�PdSXT]RT#�Pe^XS�^Qb^[TbRT]RT�P]S�
aTPRW� Xcb� _da_^bTb%
?L%� G ; 8 � G 7 B � C ? 4 G 9 B E @
?]� cWXb� bTRcX^]#� fT� STbRaXQT� W^f� cWT� JSE� _[PcU^a\� Xb�
Ud[UX[[X]V� cWT� aT`dXaT\T]cb� \T]cX^]TS� PQ^eT� P]S� QaXSVX]V� P�
R[^bT� aT[PcX^]bWX_� QTcfTT]� RXcXiT]b� P]S� _dQ[XR� PVT]cb� c^fPaSb�
X]U^a\PcX^]�TgRWP]VT�P]S�QTccTa�STRXbX^]$\PZX]V%�MT�STbRaXQT�
cWT� _[PcU^a\nb� PaRWXcTRcdaP[�STbXV]� X]� fWXRW� fT� \P]PVTS� P�
\^QX[T� P__#� P� fTQ� \^Sd[T� P]S� P]� P]P[hcXRP[� SPbWQ^PaS%� 8h�
STcPX[X]V� cWT� PePX[PQ[T� dbTa� a^[Tb� P]S� cWTXa� RdaaT]c� ^_TaPcX^]b
fXcWX]� cWT� JSE#� fT� _aTbT]c� cWT� R^\_^]T]cb� ^U� cWT� JSE�
_[PcU^a\�U^a�RXcXiT]�R^^_TaPcX^]�ST_[^hTS�X]�HD#� 8aPiX[�SdaX]V�
cWT� 9EL?:$(0� _P]ST\XR%
0#� 0XJOPZLJZ[XL� =\LX\PL]
JWT� _[PcU^a\� WPb� cWaTT� X]cTaUPRT� \^Sd[Tb#� cWT� \^QX[T�0WW!�
cWT� ELI� C8� P]S� cWT� 3HYOIVHXK#� I^\T� Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb� PaT�
TgR[dbXeT� c^� P� _PacXRd[Pa� X]cTaUPRT� \^Sd[T#� P]S� cWTh� RP]� QT�
PRRTbbTS� Qh� SXUUTaT]c� dbTa� a^[Tb#� Pb� fT� STcPX[� [PcTa� ^]� cWXb�
bTRcX^]%� ?]� cWT� _[PcU^a\� VT]TaP[� PaRWXcTRcdaT� !bTT� <XVdaT� ("#�
fT� bT_PaPcT� bdQbhbcT\b� X]c^�5HJHKL�:H_LX!� 8UZLNXHZPVU�:H_LX!�
0UHS_ZPJY� 4UNPUL� P]S� cWT� A6LV:�;PKKSL]HXL#� JWT� X]cTaUPRTb�
PaT� bd__[XTS� fXcW� SPcP� _a^eXSTS� Qh� cWT� 5HJHKL� :H_LX!� fWXRW�
Xb� R^\_^bTS� Qh� P� bTc� ^U� H;IJ� 7F?b� cWPc� PaT� _a^cTRcTS� fXcW�
P� bTRdaXch� \TRWP]Xb\%� JWTbT� 7F?b� X]cTaPRc� fXcW� cWT� X]cTaUPRT�
\^Sd[Tb� aTRTXeX]V� P]S� bT]SX]V� SPcP� c^� cWT� X]cTaUPRTb� P]S� c^�
cWT� 8UZLNXHZPVU�:H_LX#� ?]� ^da�STbXV]#� cWT�3HYOIVHXK�^][h� R^]$
bd\Tb� SPcP%� ?]R^\X]V� SPcP�Xb� aTRTXeTS�Qh� cWT� UPRPST�7F?b� P]S�
ST[XeTab� c^� cWT� X]cTVaPcX^]� 7F?b� U^a� bc^aPVT%� JWT� 8UZLNXHZPVU�
:H_LX�P[b^� R^]]TRcb� SXUUTaT]c� b^daRTb� ^U�SPcP#� X]R[dSX]V� BOPXK"�
WHXZ_� 0WWY!� c^� _a^eXST� c^� cWT� Ua^]c� UPRPST%� JWT� 8UZLNXHZPVU�
:H_LX� P[b^� WPb� ^]T� \^aT� [TeT[� ^U� bTRdaXch� Qh� bcP]SX]V� fXcWX]�
P� _aXePcT� ]Tcf^aZ%
J^� \P]PVT� dbTa� PRRTbb� R^]ca^[� P]S� bd__^ac� TUUXRXT]c� VT^$
VaP_WXR� SPcP�bc^aPVT� P]S�`dTah#� fT�dbT�cWT�A6LV:�;PKKSL]HXL�
N.O%� ?c� _a^eXSTb� P]� 7F?� U^a� P� \d[cX$P__[XRPcX^]� T]eXa^]\T]c�
X]� fWXRW� cWT� dbTa� _Ta\XbbX^]� ^]� [PhTab� ^U� VT^b_PcXP[� X]U^a$
\PcX^]� RP]� QT� \P]PVTS� TPbX[h%� <X]P[[h#� ^da�0UHS_ZPJY�4UNPUL�
R^\_aXbTb� cWT� bTc� ^U� c^^[b� U^a� X\_[T\T]cX]V� P]P[hcXRP[� P]S�
b_PcX^cT\_^aP[�^_TaPcX^]b#� U^a�TgP\_[T#� SXVXcP[�R^]cPRc�caPRX]V#�
X]SXeXSdP[nb�aXbZ�bcPcdb�P]S�^cWTab%� ?c�_a^eXSTb�c^�cWT�X]cTVaPcX^]�
[PhTa� aTUX]TS� aTbd[cb� Ua^\� cWTbT� ^_TaPcX^]b%
<XV%� (1� EeTaeXTf� ^U� cWT� JSE� R^\_^]T]cb� P]S� cWTXa� X]cTaPR$
cX^]b%
1#� CYLX� XVSLY
JWT� a^[Tb� X]� JSE� RP]� QT� a^dVW[h� SXeXSTS� Pb� RXcXiT]b#�
_aXePcT� X]bcXcdcX^]b� P]S� _dQ[XR� PVT]cb#� TPRW� fXcW� _PacXRd[Pa�
Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb%� 7]h^]T� RP]� PRc� Pb� P� RXcXiT]� X]� cWT� _[PcU^a\
Authorized licensed use limited to: IEEE Xplore. Downloaded on March 04,2021 at 13:22:49 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply. 
9HQJ�QR@RSQ
6316
+@PPN�=DPLDKGN
$4̂ �=
3D@EKDR�Y�Z�6ODM:RPDDR4@O�BNMRPHAS
4;KH
9DFHQRDP�PDONPR
4@R@K��4HBPNPPDFH@N�CD�5@R@K��9DFH@N
0DNFP@EHB@� 2MRDPL DCH@PW�CD�5@R@K�� 9HN�0P@MCD
CN�5NPRD��5NPRGD@QR�9DFHNM��+P@XHK
7>8H G�BL�F?G@+�
��2;J;A�(
=DPW�GHFG
?NS�L@W�G@C�BNMR@BR�UHRG�@M�
HMEDBRDC�ODPQNM
;GHQ�BNMR@BR�NBBSPPDC�(�C@WQ�@FN�UHRG�
@OOPNVHL@RDKW�# (�LDRDPQ�CHQR@MBD
-A8GG?<?98H?DCG
,
2;J;A�$
<MCDEHMDC
?NSP�BSPPDMR�KNB@RHNM�HQ�MNR�
T@KHC �4@JD�QSPD�WNSP�07:�HQ�
DM@AKDC
, ?NSP�PDFHNM�G@Q�@�KNU�P@RD�NE
HMEDBRDC�ODNOKD�@MC�GHFG
3NU QNBH@K�HQNK@RHNM 
@
,
2;J;A�&
?NSP�PDFHNM�G@Q�@�KNU�P@RD�NE�
HMEDBRDC�ODNOKD�@MC�KNU�
QNBH@K�HQNK@RHNM 
89,NCD
JE:;
52/5
6;:�9D:;
!P"� 9aTPcX]V� P� ST]d]RXPcX^]#� X]SX$� !Q"� IcPcdb� aXbZ� R[PbbXUXRPcX^]� P]S� !R"� GH�WTP[cW�R^ST�X]�aTS#� X]SXRPc$
RPcX]V� Xcb� [^RPcX^]%� STbRaX_cX^]%� X]V� P�WXVW�aXbZ%� !S"�?]eXcPcX^]�U^a�P]�X]UTRcX^db�cTbc%
<XV%� )1� ;gP\_[Tb� ^U�X]cTaPRcX^]� ^U�cWT� P__[XRPcX^]nb� Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb%
fXcW� Xcb� ^f]� _Tab^]P[� _a^UX[T%� JWT� ^cWTa� a^[Tb� RP]� ^][h� QT�
aTVXbcTaTS� Qh� cWT� JSE� \P]PVT\T]c� bcPUU%� 9XcXiT]� dbTab� RP]�
^_TaPcT� cWT� 0WW!� cWT� ELI� C8� P]S� ^U� R^dabT#� cWT� BOPXK"WHXZ_�
0WWY� cWPc�WPeT�P�_Pac]TabWX_�fXcW�JSE%� MXcWX]�^da�TR^bhbcT\#�
cWTh� RP]� !X"� P]^]h\^db[h� RaTPcT� ST]d]RXPcX^]b� fXcW� P]� ^_T]�
cTgc�UXT[S#� Pbb^RXPcT�Xcb� RPcTV^ah�P]S�^_cX^]P[[h�_a^eXST�_W^c^b2�
!XX"� RWTRZ� bcPcdb� ^U�cWT� ST]d]RXPcX^]b� RaTPcTS2� !XXX"� caPRZ� SPX[h�
X]U^a\PcX^]#� bdRW�Pb� PQ^dc�cWTXa�^f]�laXbZ�bcPcdbm� !bTT�ITRcX^]�
?L$;"#� cWT� RXchnb� b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]� [TeT[#� P]S� cWT� ]d\QTa� ^U�
9EL?:$(0� RPbTb2� !Xe"� bWPaT� cWXb� X]U^a\PcX^]� X]� b^RXP[� \TSXP2�
!Xe"�X]U^a\�bh\_c^\b�P]S�R^\^aQXSXch2� !e"�aTRTXeT#� PRRT_c�P]S�
STR[X]T�P�bRWTSd[TS�X]eXcPcX^]�U^a�X]UTRcX^db� cTbcX]V� P]S�UX]P[[h�
!eX"� aTRTXeT#� PRRT_c�P]S�STR[X]T� P�aT`dTbc�U^a�U^[[^f$d_� cTbcX]V�
Qh� h^da� T\_[^hTa%� E][h� Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb� !XXX"� P]S� !Xe"� aT`dTbc�
[^RPcX^]� SPcP� Ua^\� cWT� dbTa#� b^� cWT� aTbc� ZTT_� f^aZX]V� UX]T� XU�
cWTh� STR[X]T� c^� bWPaT� =FI� SPcP%
MXcW� aTVPaSb� c^� cWT� F aXePcT� X]bcXcdcX^]� dbTa#� cWTh� WPeT� cWT�
bP\T� Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb#� Qdc� ^]T� \^aT%� JWTh� RP]� R^]bd[c� cWT� aXbZ�
bcPcdb� ^U�cWTXa� T\_[^hTTb� X]� ^aSTa� c^� ZTT_� cWT\� Pc� W^\T� P]S�
Pe^XS� R^]cP\X]PcX^]� ^U� cWT� ^cWTab%� JWT� dbTa� ]TTSb� c^� PRRT_c�
cWT� _aXePcT� X]bcXcdcX^]� aT`dTbc� c^� \^]Xc^a� cWTXa� WTP[cW#� b^� XU�
cWT� dbTa� S^Tb� ]^c� fP]c� c^� bWPaT#� WXb� ^a�WTa�X]U^a\PcX^]� Xb� ]^c�
bWPaTS%
MWX[T� ]^a\P[� dbTab� X]cTaPRc�fXcW�cWT� _[PcU^a\�fXcW�cWT�0WW�
P]S� cWT� ELI� C8!� FdQ[XR� PVT]c� dbTab� ]PeXVPcT� X]� cWT� ELI� C8�
P]S� cWT� 3HYOIVHXK%� ?]� cWT� ELI� C8#� cWTbT� dbTab� RP]� !X"� PccT]S�
P]S� RWP]VT� cWT� bcPcdb� !Ua^\� l^_T]TSm� c^� ld]STa� P]P[hbXbm#
lU^afPaSTSm#� lX]� aTb^[dcX^]m� ^a� lR[^bTSm"� ^U� ^]T� ^a� \^aT�
ST]d]RXPcX^]b� aT`dTbcb2� !XX"� bT[TRc� dbTab� c^� bRWTSd[T� X]UTRcX^db�
cTbcX]V� P]S� !XXX"� X]SXRPcTb� cWT� cTbc� aTbd[cb� ^U� X]SXeXSdP[b%� JWT�
_a^RTSdaT� U^a� RW^^bX]V� RXcXiT]� dbTab� c^� X]UTRcX^db� cTbcb� Xb�
STbRaXQTS� [PcTa� X]� ITRcX^]� ?L$<%� ?]� cWT� :PbWQ^PaS� !<XVdaT� *"#�
_dQ[XR� PVT]cb� RP]�eXbdP[XiT� !Xe"� \P_b� ^U�ST]d]RXPcX^]�R[dbcTab#�
!e"� b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]� [TeT[� ^eTa� cX\T� X]� P[[� RXcXTb� P]S� cWTXa�
]TXVWQ^aW^^Sb� P]S� !eX"� cWT� ]d\QTa� ^U� 9EL?:$(0� RPbTb� X]�
P[[� RXcXTb%
2#� 6>A"IHYLK�JVUZHJZ� ZXHJPUN�
Eda� \^ST[� RT]caP[XiTb� =FI� SPcP� c^� caPRT� R^]cPRcb� fXcW�
X]UTRcTS�dbTab� P]S�eXadb�W^c�i^]Tb%� J^�R^]bXSTa�cWT�R^]caXQdcX^]�
^U�T]eXa^]\T]cP[� caP]b\XbbX^]�N*O#� ^da� P__a^PRW�Xb� c^� STcTRc� P�
R^]cPRc�Pb�cWT�TeT]c�^U�P�b_PcX^cT\_^aP[�fX]S^fTS�X]cTabTRcX^]#�
^a� _daT[h� b_PcXP[#� QTcfTT]� P]� X]UTRcTS� _Tab^]� P]S� P]� ]^]$
X]UTRcTS� dbTa%� MT� dbT� SPcP�Ua^\�cf^� b^daRTb#� !X"� cWT� P__� dbTab�
[^RPcX^]b� !bP\_[TS� TeTah� ,� \X]dcTb"� P]S� !XX"� cWT� PSSaTbbTb�
^U� P[[� X]UTRcTS� _Tab^]b� cWPc� aT_^acTS� UXabc� bh\_c^\b� X]� cWT�
[Pbc� U^dacTT]� SPhb� QTU^aT#� PRR^aSX]V� c^� cWT� WTP[cW� PdcW^aXcXTb%�
<Xabc[h#� cWT�caPSXcX^]P[� b_PcX^cT\_^aP[�R^]cPRc�Xb� STcTRcTS�fWT]�
P]� X]bcP]RT� ^U� !X"� X]cTabTRcb� cWT� b_PRT$cX\T� fX]S^f� ^U� P]�
X]bcP]RT� ^U� !X"� [XbcTS� X]� !XX"#� X%T%� P]� dbTa� Ra^bbX]V� P]� X]UTRcTS�
dbTa� cWPc� WPS� cWT� UXabcb� bh\_c^\b� aTRT]c[h%� 7� _daT� b_PcXP[�
R^]cPRc�Xb�R^]bXSTaTS�fWT]�P]�X]bcP]RT�^U�!X"�X]cTabTRcb�P�b_PcXP[�
Q^d]SPah� Pa^d]S� cWT� aTbXST]RT� PSSaTbb� ^U� !XX"%� MT� PaT� dbX]V�
*'� \X]dcTb� P]S� ),� \TcTab� U^a�cWT� b_PcX^cT\_^aP[�fX]S^f#� P]S�
),� \TcTab� U^a� cWT� _daT� b_PcXP[� fX]S^f%
Authorized licensed use limited to: IEEE Xplore. Downloaded on March 04,2021 at 13:22:49 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply. 
/?GHDF?9D� �� 0GDA8B;CHD� �� /?GH� 48H8A "'� � !#&%$
Z� 4@O@�
! � -@QGAN@PC�
0 � 1HQRCPHBN
2MCHBD�CD�9HQBN�
2QNK@LDMRN
2QNK@LDMRN�TQ�5NT@Q�B@QNQ� [[� > 1HQR �4SMHBHOHNQ� [[� >
J � 68C@?C=
.8:DG�:;�&%"$*"&$&$
;HPNK
,@OHL�4@BHN�
5U@� -DQBNAQPR@�
7BRPNONKHQ�
*PQH@� 7PDR@�
4@B�3SHX@�
7P@H@�-N�4@HN�
,@MCDK@PH@�
3@FN@�5NT@�
5@NONKHQ�
9NB@Q�
:@MRNQ�9@HQ�
,HC@CB�*KR@�
9HADHP@�
7NMR@�5BFP@�
7HRHLAS�
+@PPN�=@PL@KGN�
:@KHM@Q�
*KDBPHL�
3@FN@�:@B@�
9@CHMG@�
� !�:DOR�9NQ@CN�
5NQQ@�:@MGNP@�-N�5@X@PN�
7@ISB@P@�
7NRQMFH�
2F@ON
5NQQ@�:NMGNP@�-@�*OPDQDMR@ 
3@FN@�*XSK�
8SHMR@Q�
,HC@C@�5NT@�
5NPC@QRD�
,HC@CB�-@�.QO@P@MB@�
+NL�7@QRNP�
7K@M@KRN�
0S@P@OBQ�
/DKHOD�,@L@P@N
$�� %$�� &$�� '$�� ($�� )$�� *$�
2QNK@LDMRN�95�[[� >
"! #�" " ��� )$#&�
9\[`RV[Y\6B �
<_\YNZR[`\�_\PVNY
'" !!
&$ !!
%& !!
$& !!
$& !!
#" !!
&$�,EF� 38L� &$� &$�38L� 1IC� M&$� A51IC
3D@EKDR�Y�):�;RHSMCDPENPDQR��Z �6ODM:RPDDR4@O�BNMRPHASRNPQ
<XV%� *1� :PbWQ^PaS� \P_� ^U� b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]� [TeT[b� ^eTa� cX\T� Pc� ]TXVWQ^aW^^S� [TeT[� U^a� DPcP[#� 8aPiX[%
9W^^bX]V� P�b_PRT$cX\T�fX]S^f� RP]�QT� P]�PaQXcaPah� cPbZ�cWPc�
bW^d[S� R^]bXSTa� cWT� X\_PRcb� ^U� P� WXVW� UP[bT$_^bXcXeT� aPcT#� P]S�
^cWTa�ad[Tb� \Ph�QT� ]TRTbbPah�c^� Pe^XS� TgPVVTaPcTS� P\^d]cb� ^U�
]^cXUXRPcX^]b%� IX]RT� caPSXcX^]P[� 8[dTc^^cW$QPbTS� \TcW^Sb� \Ph�
]^c� P[Tac� fWT]� P]� X]UTRcTS� _Tab^]� Ra^bbTb� P� eXadb� W^c� i^]T#�
cWT� SXUUTaT]RT� X]� cWT� UaT`dT]Rh� ^U� ]^cXUXRPcX^]� Xb� bXV]XUXRP]c#�
Qdc� Xc�Xb� ]^c�X]�cWT� bR^_T� ^U�cWXb� bcdSh� c^� TeP[dPcT� Xc%� J^� T]bdaT�
cWPc� cWTaT� PaT� ]^c� b^� \P]h� UP[bT� _^bXcXeTb#� fT� ^][h� ]^cXUh� P�
R^]cPRc� eXP� cWT� P__� XU� cWTaT� fPb� \^aT� cWP]� ^]T� R^]cPRc� X]�
cWT� SPh� P]S� XU� cWT� PeTaPVT� R^]cPRc� SXbcP]RT� fPb� [Tbb� cWP]� *'�
\TcTab%� JWXb�aTSdRTS�cWT�^eTaP[[�P\^d]c�^U�R^]cPRc�]^cXUXRPcX^]�
X]� PeTaPVT� Qh� .'�� P� SPh%� 7[cW^dVW� cWTaT� Xb� ]^c� P� R[TPa� P]S�
aTPb^]PQ[T� R^]bT]bdb� ^]� SXVXcP[� R^]cPRc�caPRX]V�\TcW^S^[^VXTb�
P]S� cTRW]X`dTb#� fT� PaVdT� cWPc� ^dab� fTaT� STbXV]� PX\X]V� c^�
X]e^[eT� \^aT� RXcXiT]b�fXcW� b^RXP[�SXbcP]RX]V� P]S�c^�\PZT�cWT\�
Pe^XS�Z]^f]�SP]VTa^db�caPYTRc^aXTb%�MT�SXbRdbb�dbTab�UTTSQPRZ�
^]� ^da� R^]cPRc� caPRX]V� P__a^PRW� X]� ITRcX^]� L%
HTVPaSX]V� _aXePRh� [TeT[b#� ^da� P__a^PRW� _a^eXSTb� _aXePRh�
Ua^\� b]^^_Tab� !B?"#� Ua^\� ^cWTa� dbTab� !B)"� P]S� P[b^� _PacXP[[h�
Ua^\�cWT�V^eTa]\T]c�!B*"#� Pb�fT�SXbRdbbTS�X]�ITRcX^]�??%� MXcW�
aTVPaSb� c^� bRP[PQX[Xch#� fT� RdaaT]c[h� S^� ]^c� \P]PVT� aTP[$cX\T�
R^]cPRc� caPRX]V#� P]S� fT� R^\_dcT� b_PcXP[� Y^X]b� ^U� X]cTabTRcX^]�
QTcfTT]� X]UTRcTS� P]S� dbTab� _^bXcX^]b� X]� QPcRW#� cfXRT� P� SPh�
aT_^acX]V� R^]cPRcb%
3#� :L\LS� V M�YVJPHS� PYVSHZPVU
:daX]V�cWT�_P]ST\XR#� ^]T� fPh� c^�\TPbdaT�_T^_[Tnb� T]VPVT$
\T]c� X]� R^]cPX]X]V� cWT� eXadb� Xb� c^� \^]Xc^a� cWT� [TeT[� ^U� b^RXP[�
Xb^[PcX^]%� ?]� 8aPiX[#� cWT� \^QX[T� cTRW]^[^Vh� R^\_P]h� ?][^R^
STeT[^_TS� P� \TcaXR� U^a� b_PcX^cT\_^aP[� \P__X]V� ^U� b^RXP[�
Xb^[PcX^]�dbX]V�[^RPcX^]�SPcP�Ua^\�\X[[X^]b�^U�STeXRTb%�JWa^dVW�
P� _Pac]TabWX_� fXcW� CFHD#� ?][^R^� SPX[h� _a^eXSTb� cWT� [TeT[� ^U�
b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]� ^]� cWT� bRP[T� ^U� RXcXTb� P]S� ]TXVWQ^aW^^Sb� X]�
cWT� \PX]� RXcXTb� ^U� cWT� bcPcT� N/O%� ?]� cWT� bcPcT� ^U� HD#� cWTh�
RP[Rd[PcT�cWT�\TcaXR�fXcW�[^RPcX^]�SPcP�Ua^\�\^aT�cWP]�.''#'''�
_W^]Tb%� JWT� P[V^aXcW\� U^a� _a^SdRX]V� cWXb� \TcaXR� Xb� ^f]TS� Qh�
cWT� R^\_P]h#� Qdc� cWTh� _a^eXST� P� aT[XPQ[T� _aXePRh� _^[XRh%� JWT�
R^[[TRcX^]� ^U�[^RPcX^]� SPcP�Qh� ?][^R^� Xb� \PST� fXcW^dc� SXaTRc[h�
[X]ZX]V� cWT� _Tab^]P[� XST]cXUXRPcX^]� fXcW� cWT� bc^aTS� R^^aSX]PcTb#�
b^� cWTh� R[PX\� cWT� SPcP� Xb� P]^]h\XiTS%� 8h� d_SPcX]V� cWT� [TeT[�
^U� b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]� ^]� P� SPX[h� QPbXb#� P[[� dbTab� ^U� cWT� JSE�
RP]� WPeT� P� aT[XPQ[T� P]S� aTRT]c[h� d_SPcTS� _TaRT_cX^]� ^U� W^f�
b^RXTch� Xb� X]e^[eTS� X]� R^]cPX]X]V� cWT� eXadb%� MT� bW^f� cWXb�
\TcaXR� X]�P[[�X]cTaUPRTb#� 7__#� MTQ�K?�P]S�:PbWQ^PaS%� <XVdaT� *�
X[[dbcaPcTb� :PbWQ^PaS� bRaTT]� fXcW� cWT� [TeT[� ^U� b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]�
X]� P� ]TXVWQ^aW^^S� ^U�DPcP[#� cWT� bcPcT� RP_XcP[%
4#� @PYR�YZHZ[Y� HUK�?@� OLHSZO� JVKL
J^� X]U^a\� X]UTRcX^db� aXbZ� U^a� X]SXeXSdP[� dbTab� X]� JSE� aT_$
aTbT]c#� fT� R^\_dcT� P� bX\_[T� \TcaXR� fXcW� cWT� RdaaT]c� RXchnb�
b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]� [TeT[#� ]d\QTa� ^U� RPbTb� P]S� fWTcWTa� cWT� dbTa�
WPS� P� R^]cPRc� X]� cWT� [Pbc� (+� SPhb%� ?c� Xb� SXeXSTS� X]� UXeT�
[TeT[b1� b[UKLMPULKc!� l� SV]m#� l� TLKP[T
CUKLMPULK�Xb� bW^f]�fWT]�=FI� ]^c�PePX[PQ[T�^a�cWT�R^^aSX]PcTb�
X]SXRPcT�^dcbXST�cWT�HD�bcPcT2�cWT� SV]�[TeT[�Xb� bW^f]�fWT]�dbTa�
aTVX^]� WPb� P� [^f� aPcT� ^U�X]UTRcTS� _T^_[T#� WXVW� b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]�
P]S� cWT� P[V^aXcW\� SXS� ]^c� XST]cXUh� P� _^bbXQ[T� R^]cPRc� fXcW�
X]UTRcTS2� TLKP[T� Xb� caXVVTaTS� fWT]� cWT� dbTa� aTVX^]� WPb� P� [^f
Authorized licensed use limited to: IEEE Xplore. Downloaded on March 04,2021 at 13:22:49 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply. 
aPcT�^U�X]UTRcTS�_T^_[T#�[^f�b^RXP[�Xb^[PcX^]�P]S�SXS�]^c�XST]cXUh�
P� _^bbXQ[T� R^]cPRc� fXcW� X]UTRcTS2� Xb� SXb_[PhTS� fWT]� cWT�
dbTa� aTVX^]� WPb� P� WXVW� aPcT� ^U� X]UTRcTS� _T^_[T#� [^f� b^RXP[�
Xb^[PcX^]�Qdc�P[V^aXcW\�SXS�]^c�XST]cXUh� P�_^bbXQ[T�R^]cPRc�fXcW�
X]UTRcTS2� P]S�UX]P[[h� \LX_�OPNO� P__TPa�fWT]� Xc�Xb� [XZT[h�cWPc�cWT�
dbTa� WPS� R^]cPRc� fXcW� P]� X]UTRcTS� _Tab^]� ^a� P� eXadb� W^c� i^]T%
7b� P]^cWTa� aXbZ� PbbTbb\T]c� \TcaXR#� fT� STeT[^_TS� cWT� GH�
WTP[cW� R^ST� cWPc�RP]�QT� VaTT]#� ^aP]VT� ^a�aTS%� MWT]� P�dbTa�WPb�
P� R^]cPRc#� ^a� fWX[T� WT&bWT� Xb� X]UTRcTS#� cWTaT� fX[[�QT� P�aTS� R^ST�
P]S� P� R^d]cS^f]� ^U�U^dacTT]� SPhb%� 7UcTa� bTeT]� SPhb#� cWT� R^ST�
RWP]VTb� c^� ^aP]VT� XU�]^� R^]cPRcb� fTaT� PVPX]� U^d]S%� MWT]� cWT�
R^d]cS^f]� WXcb� '#� ^a�XU�fT� SXS� ]^c� STcTRc� P]h� R^]cPRc#� cWT�dbTa�
aTRTXeTb� cWT� VaTT]� R^ST%� JWT� GH�WTP[cW� R^ST� Xb� SXUUTaT]c�Ua^\�
cWT� aXbZ� bcPcdb� X]� cWT� bT]bT� cWPc� Xc� Xb� eP[XS� Pb� XST]cXUXRPcX^]�
U^a� _dQ[XR� PVT]cb� PQ^dc� dbTabn� X]UTRcX^db� aXbZ%� <^a� TgP\_[T#�
9WX]P� WPb� dbTS� R^[^da$QPbTS� GH� WTP[cW� R^ST� U^a� R^]ca^[[X]V�
caP]b_^acPcX^]�bhbcT\b#�Qdc�X]�P�SXUUTaT]c�R^]cTgc�^U�aTbcaXRcX^]b�
P]S� [^f� P[V^aXcW\� caP]b_PaT]Rh� N0O%
5#� AJOLK[SLK� PUMLJZPV[Y� ZLYZPUN
KbX]V� X]U^a\PcX^]� PQ^dc� dbTab� R^\^aQXSXcXTb#� ]^cXUXTS� R^]$
cPRcb#� [Pbc� bh\_c^\b� aT_^acTS� P]S� PVT#� _dQ[XR� PVT]cb� dbTab�
RP]� bT[TRc� P]S� X]eXcT� dbTab� c^� P� bRWTSd[TS� X]UTRcX^db� cTbc%�
JWT� _a^RTbb� RP]� QT� bd\\PaXiTS� Pb� X]� <XVdaT� +%� 7]� X]eXcPcX^]�
caXVVTab� P� ]^cXUXRPcX^]� ^]� cWT� 7__#� P]S� cWT� dbTa� RP]� PRRT_c� ^a�
STR[X]T�Xc%�7UcTa�cPZX]V�P]S�PccT]SX]V�c^�cWT�cTbc�X]�cWT�[^RP[�P]S�
cX\T� X]SXRPcTS#� cWT� WTP[cW� PVT]c� R^[[TRcb� P]S� bW^d[S� X]SXRPcT�
fWTcWTa� cWT� cTbcTS� X]SXeXSdP[b� WPeT� _^bXcXeT� aTbd[cb� fXcWX]� cWT�
P__%� JWXb� fX[[� X\\TSXPcT[h� bd__[h� cWT� JSE� SPcPQPbTb� U^a� cWT�
R^]cPRc� caPRX]V� P[V^aXcW\#� aXbZ� bcPcdb� P]S� TeT]cdP[[h� XU� WXb� ^a�
WTa� T\_[^hTa� Xb� aTVXbcTaTS#� Xc� fX[[� QT� bW^f]� U^a� cWT� [PccTa� c^�
U^aVXeT� WX\� ^a� WTa� Ua^\� f^aZ� X]� cWT� R^\X]V� SPhb%
g � "
^ S N h � [� � a
n 2 3 � 7 (� 43+4 )�
;RNY`U�4TR[` !� 
k [ X _RYRP`��� _PURQaYR�a_R^_ H_R^_�N^R
C^R$_RYRP`V\[�\S�a_R^_ [\`VSVRQ�`\�]^R_R[`
S\^�`R_`V[T DE�URNY`U�P\QR
6Y\_R�P\[`NP`_�N^R�[\`VSVRQ�I%
H_R^_�^RPRVbR�
`R_`�^R_aY`_
;RNY`U�4TR[`_�
P\YYRP`�`R_`_
<XV%� +1� IT[TRcXeT� X]UTRcX^db� cTbcX]V� f^aZU[^f%
I%� 7 < F 6 H F F < B A
?]�cWXb� bTRcX^]#� fT�STcPX[�cWT�VT]TaP[�X]�fWXRW�JSE� PRWXTeTS�
P� WXVWTa� PdSXT]RT� P]S� X]� fWPc� R^]cTgc� Xc� fPb� ST_[^hTS#�
R^\_PaTS�c^�P__b� Pa^d]S�cWT�f^a[S�P]S�fWT]� P]P[hbTS�[^RP[[h�
VXeT]� dbTa� UTTSQPRZ%
0#� >HXZULXYOPWY
ITeTaP[� _Pac]TabWX_b� fTaT� \PST� c^� X]cTVaPcT� _dQ[XR� PVT]cb�
fXcW� dbTUd[� UTPcdaTb� P]S� PRWXTeT� WXVWTa� aTPRW� X]� b^RXTch%� 7b�
\T]cX^]TS� X]� ITRcX^]� )#� cWT� JSE� _[PcU^a\� fPb� STeT[^_TS�
fXcWX]� cWT� DPcP[� I\Pac� 9Xch� X]XcXPcXeT#� Qh� cWT� d]XeTabXch� P]S�
cWT�_dQ[XR�\X]Xbcah%� ?]�cWXb�_a^RTbb#�cWT� bcPcT�WTP[cW�ST_Pac\T]c�
!I;I7F&HD"� fPb� cWT� \^bc� X\_^acP]c� TgcTa]P[� _Pac]Ta#� _a^$
eXSX]V� SPcP#� WT[_X]V� c^� SXbbT\X]PcT� cWT� _[PcU^a\� X]� cWT� bcPcT�
P]S� R^]cX]d^db[h� dbX]V� cWT� Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb� U^a� WTP[cW� PVT]cb%�
>^fTeTa#� Xc� fPb� ]^c� cWT� ^][h� TbbT]cXP[� ^]T%� JWT� R^\_P]h�
?][^R^� R^[[PQ^aPcTS� _a^eXSX]V� SPX[h� X]U^a\PcX^]� PQ^dc� b^RXP[�
Xb^[PcX^]�[TeT[�X]�P[[�RXcXTb�^U�cWT� bcPcT� N/O#� cWa^dVW�P]^]h\XiTS�
SXb_[PRT\T]c� \TcaXRb� ^U� \^aT� cWP]� .''#'''� dbTab%� JWT� bcPcT�
cPg� ^UUXRT� !I;J&HD"� R^[[PQ^aPcTS� cWa^dVW� cWT� X]cTVaPcX^]� fXcW�
Xcb� ^UUXRXP[� P__[XRPcX^]#� fWXRW� TgRWP]VTb� X]U^a\PcX^]� fXcW�
cWT� JSE� P__� PQ^dc� aXbZ� bcPcdb%� JWT� UTSTaPcX^]� ^U� X]SdbcaXTb�
!<?;HD"� P[b^�R^[[PQ^aPcTS�Qh�T]R^daPVX]V�R^\_P]XTb�c^�PS^_c�
cWT� JSE�fXcW� cWTXa� T\_[^hTTb%� JWT� bcPcT� _dQ[XR� bPUTch� ST$
_Pac\T]c� !I;I;:&HD"� fPb� P]� X\_^acP]c� _Pac]Ta� dbX]V� cWT�
SPbWQ^PaS�c^�SXbcaXQdcT�_Pca^[b� X]� PVV[^\TaPcX^]� bXcTb#� \TTcX]V�
cWT� ST\P]Sb� ^U�dbTab%� JWT� _dQ[XR� \X]Xbcah� P]S� cWT� d]XeTabXch�
PaT� R^]cX]dP[[h� [^^ZX]V� U^a� ]Tf� R^[[PQ^aPcX^]� c^� X]cTVaPcT�
X\_^acP]c� bcPZTW^[STab� P]S� c^� _a^eXST� \^aT� dcX[XcXTb� c^� cWT�
RXcXiT]b%� JWT� _[PcU^a\� f^d[S� RTacPX][h� WPeT� P� \^STbc� P]S�
[X\XcTS� aTPRW� fXcW^dc�_Pac]TabWX_b� QTcfTT]� _dQ[XR� P]S� _aXePcT�
X]bcXcdcX^]b%
1#� 2VTWHXPYVU� ]PZO� XLSHZLK�HWWY
JWa^dVW^dc� cWT� f^a[S#� \^QX[T� P__[XRPcX^]b� WPeT� QTT]� ST$
_[^hTS� SdaX]V� cWXb� _P]ST\XR� UPRX]V� SXUUTaT]c� Rd[cdaP[#� TR^$
]^\XR#� b^RXP[� P]S� _^[XcXRP[� bRT]PaX^b%
C^bc� P__b� WPS� P� \^STbc� bcPac� P]S� Te^[eTS� X]� cTa\b� ^U�]Tf�
Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb#� X]U^a\PcX^]� PRRdaPRh� P]S� SPcP� _a^cTRcX^]� PUcTa�
aXVXS�_dQ[XR� bRadcX]h%� ?]�cWT�KA#� cWT�]PcX^]P[�WTP[cW� PdcW^aXcXTb�
STeT[^_TS� P� \d[cX_da_^bT� P__� cWPc� ^][h� [Pd]RWTS� R^]cPRc�
caPRX]V� P]S� cTbcX]V� Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb� X]� @d]T#� P]S� Xc� bcX[[� RWP]VTS�
Xcb� P__a^PRW� c^� cWT� 7__[T&=^^V[T� UaP\Tf^aZ� N('O� [PcTa� ^]�
PUcTa� cWT� _dQ[XR� RaXcXRXiTS� cWT� P__a^PRW� cPZT]%� JWa^dVW^dc�
cWT� _P]ST\XR#� cWTh� VaPSdP[[h� X]R[dSTS� UTPcdaTb� U^a� GH$QPbTS�
RWTRZ$X]#�UaTT�cTbc�Q^^ZX]V�P]S�Xb^[PcX^]�R^d]cS^f]%� IX]RT�Xc�Xb�
cWT� ^UUXRXP[� P__[XRPcX^]� X]�cWT� R^d]cah#� STeT[^_TS� Qh� cWT� WTP[cW�
PdcW^aXcXTb�fXcW�aTPSX[h�P]S�R^]bcP]c�d_SPcTb#�cWTXa�P__�aTPRWTS�
\PbbXeT� dbT#� fXcW� S^iT]b� ^U� cW^dbP]Sb� ^U� [^VX]b� TeTah� SPh�
N((O%� ?]� 9WX]P#� 7[X_Phnb� l>TP[cW� 9^STm� bhbcT\� aTPRWTS� \^aT�
cWP]� )''� RXcXTb� ]PcX^]P[$fXST#� X\_[T\T]cTS� Pb� P� _Pac]TabWX_�
QTcfTT]� QXV� cTRW� R^\_P]XTb� P]S� cWT� 9WX]TbT� V^eTa]\T]c%�
JWT� \PX]� _dQ[XR� R^]RTa]� ^]� cWT� 9WX]TbT� P__� Xb� cWT� [PRZ� ^U�
P[V^aXcW\� caP]b_PaT]Rh� N0O%� 7]^cWTa� RPbT� ^U� \PbbXeT[h� dbTS�
P__� fPb� X]� ?]SXP� !fXcW� \^aT� cWP]� ,'� \X[[X^]� S^f][^PSb� X]�
cWT� UXabc� cf^� fTTZb"#� cWT� l7Pa^VhP� ITcdm� N()O� fPb� STeT[^_TS�
Qh� cWT� V^eTa]\T]c� P]S� PUcTa� _dQ[XR� bRadcX]h� ^]� _aXePRh#� Xcb�
b^daRT� R^ST� fPb� cda]� _dQ[XR%� ?]� \P]h� ^cWTa� R^d]caXTb#� \^QX[T�
P__[XRPcX^]b�c^�bd__^ac�RXcXiT]b�SdaX]V�cWT�_P]ST\XR�WPeT�QTT]�
ST_[^hTS� d]STa� P� SXUUTaT]c� b^RXP[� R^]cTgc#� P]S� P� bhbcT\PcXR�
aTeXTf� ^U� P__a^PRWTb� fX[[� QT� ^U� VaTPc� dbT� c^� _dQ[XR� ^UUXRXP[b�
X]� cWT� R^\X]V� T_XST\XRb%� 4S`R^� N� ]^RYVZV[N^e� RdNZV[N`V\[#
Authorized licensed use limited to: IEEE Xplore. Downloaded on March 04,2021 at 13:22:49 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply. 
_dQ[XR� bRadcX]h#� V^eTa]\T]c� X]eTbc\T]cb� P]S� X]cTVaPcX^]�
fXcW� PRcXeT� P__[XRPcX^]b� X]� cWT� RXch� fTaT� cWT� \ PX]� _X[[Pab�
c^� PRWXTeT� \PbbXeT� dbT%
Eda�_[PcU^a\�fPb� R^]RTXeTS�X]� P�\^aT� \^STbc�R^]cTgc#� ^_$
TaPcX]V� Pb� P�_a^^U$^U$R^]RT_c�X]� P� bX]V[T� bcPcT� ^U�P�STeT[^_X]V�
R^d]cah%� JWT� ^UUXRXP[� R^a^]PeXadb� P__b� X]� 8aPiX[� fTaT� \^bc[h�
U^RdbTS� ^]� bT[U$SXPV]^bcXR� P]S� VT]TaP[� X]U^a\PcX^]� PQ^dc� cWT�
_P]ST\XR#� bdRW� Pb� cWT� l9^a^]PeXadb� IKIm� STeT[^_TS� Qh� cWT�
]PcX^]P[�WTP[cW�\X]Xbcah%� ?]�PSSXcX^]#� cWT�SXeXbX^]�X]c^� bcPcTb� X]�
cWT� R^d]cah� Xb� P]� X\_^acP]c� UPRc^a� fXcW� aTVPaS� c^� cWT� \^QX[T�
P__[XRPcX^]b� cWPc�WPeT�T\TaVTS%� IX\X[Pa[h�c^�cWT�K]XcTS�IcPcTb#�
bcPcT� WTP[cW� ^UUXRXP[b� WPeT� VaTPc�aTb_^]bXQX[Xch� U^a� \PX]cPX]X]V�
[^RP[� aTb^daRTb%� JWTaTU^aT#� SdaX]V� cWT� _P]ST\XR#� \P]h� P__[X$
RPcX^]� X]XcXPcXeTb� fTaT� STeT[^_TS� bT_PaPcT[h� X]� bcPcTb� PRa^bb�
cWT� R^d]cah#� b^\TcX\Tb� cWa^dVW� _dQ[XR$_aXePcT� _Pac]TabWX_b#�
fXcW^dc� Tg_[XRXc� X]cTVaPcX^]� fXcW� cWT� ]PcX^]P[� WTP[cW� \X]Xbcah%�
JWTaT� PaT� ^cWTa� X]XcXPcXeTb� Pa^d]S� cWT� R^d]cah� Pb� ^dab%� <^a�
TgP\_[T#� X]� cWT� bcPcT� ^U� FTa]P\QdR^� !F;"� cWT� :hR^eXS� P__�
N(*O#� STeT[^_TS� Qh� P� bcPac$d_� P]S� bd__^acTS� Qh� cWT� _dQ[XR�
\X]Xbcah#� P[b^� X\_[T\T]cTS�P]S� X\_a^eTS�cWTXa�SXVXcP[� R^]cPRc�
caPRX]V� P]S� bT[TRcXeT� cTbcX]V� UTPcdaTb� c^� bd__^ac� [^RP[� WTP[cW�
PdcW^aXcXTb%� :hR^eXS� ^][h� ^_TaPcTb� X]� F;#� P]S� JSE� ^][h� X]�
HD#� Pb� c^cP[[h� SXUUTaT]c�_a^YTRcb%
7[cW^dVW� fT� SXS� ]^c� PRWXTeT� \PbbXeT� dbT� PRa^bb� cWT� bcPcT#�
cWT� )'#'''� dbTab� fTaT� bdUUXRXT]c� c^� WPeT� P� aTP[� Tg_TaXT]RT� ^U�
\P]PVX]V�P�WXVW$ST\P]S�P__[XRPcX^]�X]�P�_P]ST\XR%�MT�R^d[S�
bTT#� Pb� _aTeX^db[h� SXbRdbbTS#� cWPc�_Pac]TabWX_b� P]S� X]cTVaPcX^]�
fXcW� RXch� P__b� fTaT� TgcaT\T[h� X\_^acP]c�c^� aTPRW� \^aT� dbTab%�
7[cW^dVW� fT� WPeT� ]^� SXaTRc� X]eTbc\T]c� Ua^\� cWT� V^eTa]\T]c�
c^� STeT[^_� cWT� _[PcU^a\#� P]S� cWT� _dQ[XR� bRadcX]h� fPb� ]^c� Pb�
Tg_[XRXc�Pb�X]�^cWTa�R^d]caXTb#� ^da�Tg_TaXT]RT�WPb�Qa^dVWc�^cWTa�
Pb_TRcb� cWPc� UdcdaT� P__[XRPcX^]b� \Ph� cPZT� X]c^� PRR^d]c#� Pb� fT�
fX[[� SXbRdbb� b^^]%� MT� PaVdT� cWPc� ^da� \PX]� R^]caXQdcX^]� X]�
R^\_PaXb^]� c^� aT[PcTS� P__[XRPcX^]b� fPb� cWT� bdRRTbbUd[� Tg_T$
aXT]RT� ^U� X]cTVaPcX]V� fXcW� ePaX^db� [^RP[� X]bcXcdcX^]b#� cWa^dVW�
ePaX^db� UTPcdaTb� bdRW� Pb� SXVXcP[� R^]cPRc�caPRX]V#� PVV[^\TaPcX^]�
R^\_[PX]cb#� bT[TRcXeT� X]UTRcX^db� cTbcX]V#� Pb� fT[[� Pb� aXbZ� bcPcdb�
P]S� b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]� [TeT[� \^]Xc^aX]V
2#� BK=�MVX� JPZP`LUY
J^� PbbTbb� cWT� STVaTT� c^� fWXRW� cWT� _[PcU^a\� bd__^acTS�
RXcXiT]b� SdaX]V� cWT� _P]ST\XR#� fT� R^]bXSTaTS� dbTa� UTTSQPRZ�
fXcW� P]� ^][X]T� bdaeTh%� MT� PSSaTbb� Pb_TRcb� P]S� aT`dXaT\T]cb�
SXbRdbbTS� TPa[XTa� X]� cWXb� _P_Ta%� 8h� d]STabcP]SX]V� cWT� aTbd[cb�
^QcPX]TS#� fT�TeP[dPcT�cWT�PSeP]cPVTb� P]S�SXbPSeP]cPVTb� ^U�cWT�
STRXbX^]b� fT�\PZT�c^� bTc�d_�cWT�_[PcU^a\�VXeT]�cWT�T]eXbX^]TS�
aT`dXaT\T]cb%
JWT� bdaeTh� UXabc� PbbTbbTS� _T^_[Tnb� ^_X]X^]� PQ^dc� cWT� [TeT[�
^U� T]VPVT\T]c� cWTh� QT[XTeTS� cWT� JSE� _a^eXSTS%� MT� PbZTS�
b%#� 1HYLK� VU� _V[X� L^WLXPLUJL!� OV]� T[JO� KV� _V[� ZOPUR� ZOL�
HWW� OHY� OLSWLK�_V[� ZV� LUNHNL� TVXL� ]PZO� YVJPHS� PYVSHZPVU/c#�
JWT� aTb_^]bTb� fTaT� STbXV]TS� Pb� P� bR^aT� Ua^\� (� c^� ,#� Pb�
P__� aPcX]V� bhbcT\b%� JWT� PeTaPVT� ^U�aTb_^]bTb� fPb� *%+/#� fXcW�
P� bcP]SPaS� STeXPcX^]� ^U� (%+/%� MT� R^]bXSTa� cWXb� aTbd[c� c^� QT�
aTPb^]PQ[h�_^bXcXeT#� VXeT]� cWPc�Pc�cWT� bdaeTh�SPcT#� b^\T� ^U�cWT�
\^bc� X\_^acP]c� JSE� UTPcdaTb� WPS� ]^c� hTc� QTT]� fXST[h� dbTS#
bdRW�Pb�bT[TRcXeT�X]UTRcX^db�cTbcX]V#�fWXRW�fPb�X\_[T\T]cTS�^]�
b\P[[Ta� RXcXTb� UXabc� c^� eP[XSPcT� P]S� cTbc� X\_[T\T]cPcX^]%� IcX[[#�
fT� PaT� X\_a^eX]V� cWT� _[PcU^a\� c^� aTPRW� P[[� UTPcdaTb� X]� cWT�
QXVVTbc� RXcXTb#� P]S� cWXb� UTTSQPRZ� fX[[� bTaeT� Pb� P� bcX\d[db� c^�
VdXST� UdcdaT� eTabX^]b%
JWT� bTR^]S� `dTbcX^]� fT� PbZTS� fPb� c^� PbbTbb� cWT� caP]b$
_PaT]Rh� ^U� cWT� XPYR� YZHZ[Y#� bW^fTS� Pb� X]� <XVdaT� )Q� P]S�
STbRaXQTS�X]�bTRcX^]�?L$;%�IX]RT�Xc�fPb�P�WTdaXbcXR�\TcW^S^[^Vh�
c^�_a^eXST�RXcXiT]b�fXcW�P]�X]SXRPcX^]�^U�cWT�aXbZ�cWTh�fTaT�bdQ$
YTRc�c^#� fT�R^]bXSTa�Xc�RadRXP[�cWPc�Xc�fPb� bX\_[T�c^�d]STabcP]S%�
MT� PbZTS� b&#� 7V]� PUZ[PZP\L� HUK� LHY_� ZV� [UKLXYZHUK� PY� ZOL�
PU"HWW�L^WSHUHZPVU�HIV[Z�ZOL� d@PYR�YZHZ[Yd/c#�<a^\� (� c^� ,#� cWT�
aTbd[cb�aTPRWTS�P]�PeTaPVT�^U�+%'/#�fXcW�P�bcP]SPaS�STeXPcX^]�^U�
(%)*%� =XeT]� cWT� ePaX^db� aTb^daRTb� X]� cWT� P__� Tg_[PX]X]V� PQ^dc�
cWT�XPYR�YZHZ[Y#� fT�Tg_TRcTS�cWXb�UTTSQPRZ�c^�QT�QTccTa%�?c�bW^fb�
cWPc�TeT]� fWT]� cWTaT� Xb� P]� TUU^ac�c^� \PZT� \TcaXRb� caP]b_PaT]c#�
Xc� Xb� ]^c� P� bX\_[T� cPbZ� c^� QT� c^cP[[h� d]STabcP]SPQ[T%
MT� P[b^� PbZTS� PQ^dc�dbTab� X]cTaPRcX^]b� fXcW� R^]cPRc�caPRX]V�
]^cXUXRPcX^]b%�<Xabc#�fT�PbZTS� b'#� =U�ZOL�KH_Y�ZOHZ�_V[�XLJLP\LK�
JVUZHJZ� UVZPMPJHZPVU� HIV[Z� _V[X� WVYYPISL� \PYPZ� ZV� Y[YWLJZLK�
HXLHY� V M�2=D83"%-!� KV� _V[� ILSPL\L� ZOHZ�_V[X� ZXHQLJZVX_�TH_�
OH\L�ILLU�MH\V[XHISL� ZV�NLULXHZL�HU�HSLXZ/c#� 7b�fT�Tg_[PX]TS�
X]� ITRcX^]� ?L$9#� ^da� P__a^PRW� ]PcdaP[[h� cT]Sb� c^� WPeT� P� WXVW�
aPcT� ^U�UP[bT�_^bXcXeTb%� EU�cWT� c^cP[�aTb_^]ST]cb#� ^][h� -(�� SXS�
]^c�aTRTXeT�P]h�]^cXUXRPcX^]%� EU�cWT� *0�� fW^�aTRTXeTS�Xc#� /0��
bPXS�hTb#�cWT�caPYTRc^ah�cWTh�\PST�^]�cWT�SPh�^U�cWT�]^cXUXRPcX^]�
\XVWc� WPeT� QTT]� bdbRT_cXQ[T� c^� R^]cPRc%�<^a� cWXb� aTPb^]#� fT�
aTPUUXa\�cWPc�cWT�U[TgXQX[Xch�c^�P�aT[PcXeT[h�WXVW�]d\QTa�^U�UP[bT�
_^bXcXeTb� X]� R^]cPRc� caPRX]V#� Tb_TRXP[[h� X]� R^]SXcX^]b� ^U� WXVW�
T]eXa^]\T]cP[� caP]b\XbbX^]� bdRW� Pb� X]� cWT� _P]ST\XR� 9EL?:$�
(0#� RP]� WT[_� c^� _a^eXST� P[Pa\b� P]S� c^� aT\X]S� cWT� _^_d[PcX^]�
c^� Pe^XS�]^]$TbbT]cXP[� caPYTRc^aXTb� X]� cWXb� _TaX^S%
IcX[[� ^]� R^]cPRc�caPRX]V#� fT� PbZTS� U^a� cW^bT� fW^� aTRTXeTS� P�
R^]cPRc� ]^cXUXRPcX^]� PQ^dc� cWT� _^bbXQ[T� UTT[X]V� ^U� _P]XR� cWPc�
^da� ]^cXUXRPcX^]b� \Ph� QT� VT]TaPcX]V1� b(#� 8 M �_V[� XLJLP\LK� H�
UVZPMPJHZPVU� V M�JVUZHJZ� ]PZO� HU� PUMLJZLK�WLXYVU!� ]OHZ� SL\LS� VM�
WHUPJ� YLUYHZPVU� KPK� _V[� MLLS/c#� JWT� aTb_^]bTb� fTaT� PVPX]�
PRRT_cTS� X]� P� aP]VT� Ua^\� (� c^� ,%� E]� PeTaPVT#� aTb_^]bTb�
X]SXRPcTS� P� [TeT[� ^U� *%)0#� fXcW� P� bcP]SPaS� STeXPcX^]� ^U� (%*(%�
MT�QT[XTeT�cWPc�P�c^^�[^f�aTbd[c�f^d[S�]^c�QT�P�V^^S�X]SXRPc^a�
bX]RT�cWXb�ZX]S�^U�]^cXUXRPcX^]� \dbc�STbRaXQT� P�bT]bT� ^U�SP]VTa�
P]S� P[Tac� PQ^dc� cWT� caPYTRc^ah� \PST%� MT� PaVdT� cWPc� Xc� Xb�
X\_^acP]c� c^� ]^cXUh� P� _^bbXQ[T� R^]cPRc� fXcW^dc� RPdbX]V� c^^�
\dRW�_P]XR#� bW^fX]V� cWT�SP]VTa�caP]b_PaT]c[h�P]S�X]�SXUUTaT]c�
fPhb#� U^a� TgP\_[T#� cWa^dVW� cWT� aXbZ� bcPcdb� P]S� cWT� GH� WTP[cW�
R^ST%
<dacWTa\^aT#� fT� PbbTbb� dbTabn� ^_X]X^]b� ^]� W^f� fT[[� cWT�
JSE� WPb� X]cTVaPcTS� _dQ[XR� X]bcXcdcX^]b� SdaX]V� cWT� _P]ST\XR%�
MXcW� P]bfTab� X]� cWT� bP\T�aP]VT#� fT� PbZTS� b)#� 7V]�T[JO�KV�
_V[� ILSPL\L� ZOHZ� ZOL� J[XXLUZ�MLHZ[XLY� V M�BK=� �KLU[UJPHZPVU� VM�
HNNSVTLXHZPVUY!� JVUZHJZ� ZXHJPUN!� YJOLK[SPUN� ZLYZY� HUK� YVJPHS�
PYVSHZPVU� KHZH � HXL� JHWHISL� V M�YHZPYMHJZVXPS_� PUZLNXHZPUN� JPZP"
`LUY� ]PZO� ZOL� JPZ_� OHSS!� OLHSZO� HUK� YHMLZ_� H[ZOVXPZPLY/c%� JWT�
aTb_^]bTb� X]SXRPcTS� P]� PeTaPVT� bR^aT� ^U�*%,,#� fXcW� P� bcP]SPaS�
STeXPcX^]� ^U� (%,)%
?]� UPRc#� cWTbT� aTbd[cb� \Ph� X]SXRPcT� cWPc� JSEnb� PRcX^]b
Authorized licensed use limited to: IEEE Xplore. Downloaded on March 04,2021 at 13:22:49 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply. 
_TaU^a\� aT[PcXeT[h� fT[[� U^a� P� _aT[X\X]Pah� X]XcXPcXeT#� Qdc� cWPc�
cWTaT� Xb� bcX[[� P� [^c� ^U�a^^\� U^a� X\_a^eT\T]c%� <^a� cWXb� aTPb^]#�
^da� UX]P[� `dTbcX^]� X]� cWT� bdaeTh� fPb� b*#� BVKH_!� ]OHZ� PY� ZOL�
THPU� SPTPZHZPVU� V M� BK=/c#� 7\^]V� bTeTaP[� ^_cX^]b#� cWT� c^_�
cWaTT� \^bc� X]SXRPcTS� fTaT� lJWT� [^f� UaT`dT]Rh� fXcW� fWXRW�
cWT� SPcP� Xb� d_SPcTSm� !*)�"#� l7]bfTaX]V� \h� aT_^ac� S^Tb� ]^c�
WP__T]m� !)'�"#� U^[[^fTS�Qh� lJWT� b[^f]Tbb� ^a� UPX[daTb� ^U�cWT�
P__[XRPcX^]m� !()�"%� JWT� UXabc� [X\XcPcX^]� fT� d]STabcP]S� Pb� cWT�
\PX]� ST\P]S� ^U� cWT� _^_d[PcX^]� SdaX]V� cWT� _P]ST\XR#� P]S� Xc�
bTT\b� cWPc� cWT� SPX[h� d_SPcT� Xb� bcX[[� ]^c� T]^dVW� U^a� cWT\%� JWT�
bTR^]S� ST\P]S� Xb� U^a� \^aT� R^\_[PX]cb#� fWXRW� ST_T]Sb� ^]�
cWT� _PacXRX_PcX^]� P]S� VaTPcTa� dbT� ^U� cWT� JSE� Qh� RXch� WP[[b�
P]S�_dQ[XR� bPUTch� PdcW^aXcXTb%� JWXaS#� dbTab� R^\_[PX]� PQ^dc�cWT�
PePX[PQX[Xch� ^U�cWT� P__#� fWXRW� Xb� ^]T� ^U�^da�_aX\Pah� R^]RTa]b�
U^a� \PX]cT]P]RT� P]S� X\_a^eT\T]c� ^U� bTaeXRTb%
L?%� 9B A 6 ? H F < B A
I\Pac� RXcXTb� WPeT� QTT]� RWP[[T]VTS� c^� P__[h� ?9J� X]UaPbcadR$
cdaT� c^� R^]cPX]� cWT� PSeP]RT\T]c�^U�cWT� R^a^]PeXadb� _P]ST\XR%�
9daaT]c[h#� \^QX[T� P__[XRPcX^]b� WPeT� QTT]� R^]bXSTaTS� cWT� X]$
bcad\T]cb� c^� _a^\^cT� \PbbXeT� X]U^a\PcX^]� ]Tcf^aZb� P]S� cWdb�
T]PQ[T� \TRWP]Xb\b� U^a� RXcXiT]� _PacXRX_PcX^]� X]� RXch� PRcX^]b%�
?]� cWXb� _P_Ta#� fT� [Xbc� cWT� aT`dXaT\T]cb� cWPc� fT� QT[XTeT� PaT�
RadRXP[�c^�_dccX]V�RXcXiT]b�X]�cWT�[^^_�SdaX]V�WXVW[h�R^]cPVX^db�
T_XST\XRb%�MT�_a^_^bTS�JSE#�P�_[PcU^a\�c^�X\_[T\T]c�bTeTaP[�
Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb� c^� bcX\d[PcT� cWT� X]cTaPRcX^]� QTcfTT]� RXcXiT]b#�
_dQ[XR� P]S� _aXePcT� X]bcXcdcX^]b%� JSE� _[PcU^a\� aTPRWTS� \^aT�
cWP]� )'#'''� dbTab� X]� [Tbb� cWP]� U^da� \^]cWb#� P]S� cWa^dVW�
XcTaPcXeT� X\_a^eT\T]cb� ST\^]bcaPcTS� eP[dT� U^a� RXcXiT]b� ^U�cWT�
bcPcT� ^U� HD#� 8aPiX[#� cWa^dVW� UTPcdaTb� bdRW� Pb� R^]cPRc� caPRX]V#�
bT[TRcXeT� X]UTRcX^]� cTbcX]V#� b^RXP[� Xb^[PcX^]� \^]Xc^aX]V#� P\^]V�
^cWTa� \TcaXRb%
MT� SXbRdbbTS� b^\T� ^U�cWT� TUUTRcb� ^U�^da� _[PcU^a\%� <Xabc#� Xc�
[TeTaPVTS� cWT� X]cTVaPcX^]� ^U� [^RP[� PdcW^aXcXTb#� _aXePcT� X]bcXcd$
cX^]b� P]S� RXcXiT]b� SdaX]V� cWT� _P]ST\XR� cWa^dVW� cWT� Ud]RcX^]$
P[XcXTb�PePX[PQ[T�P]S�_Pac]TabWX_b�\PST%�JWT]�fT�R^\_PaTS�^da�
_[PcU^a\� c^� aT[PcTS� P__b#� STbRaXQX]V� cWT� \PX]� SXUUTaT]RTb%� MT�
STbRaXQTS�cWT�TgcT]c�c^�fWXRW�R^\_[PX]cb� PaT�QTX]V� WP]S[TS�Qh�
[^RP[� PdcW^aXcXTb#� X]SXRPcX]V� cWT� SXUUXRd[ch� X]� T]VPVX]V� PVT]cb�
c^�STP[�fXcW�cWT\%�<X]P[[h#� fT�SXbRdbbTS�cWT�UTTSQPRZ�^U�b^\T�
PRcXeT� JSE� dbTab� ^]� cWT� ePaX^db� Ud]RcX^]P[XcXTb� P]S�^QYTRcXeTb�
^U�cWT�_[PcU^a\%� MT�XST]cXUXTS�cWPc�cWT�_[PcU^a\�WPb�_TaU^a\TS�
bPcXbUPRc^aX[h� X]� cWT� ^_X]X^]� ^U� cWT� aTb_^]ST]cb#� fXcW� [Xcc[T�
aTYTRcX^]#� STb_XcT�WPeX]V� \P]PVT\T]c�Pb_TRcb� c^�QT�X\_a^eTS%
=XeT]� cWPc� cWT� _P]ST\XR� WPb� WPS� P� _a^[^]VTS� X\_PRc� X]�
8aPiX[� P]S� cWT� Va^fX]V� TR^]^\XR� ^QbcPR[Tb� c^�ZTT_X]V� _T^_[T�
X]�`dPaP]cX]T�U^a�[^]VTa#�Tb_TRXP[[h�X]�P�STeT[^_X]V�R^d]cah#�X]$
]^ePcX^]b�X]�RXcXiT]�R^[[PQ^aPcX^]�\dbc�R^]bcP]c[h�QT�_a^_^bTS�
c^�X\_a^eT�cWT� `dP[Xch� ^U�[XUT%� ?]�UPRc#� cWXb� Xb� ]^c�P� bX\_[T�cPbZ�
P]S� \dbc� X]e^[eT� X]cTVaPcTS� PRcX^]b� Pc� SXUUTaT]c� X]bcXcdcX^]P[�
[TeT[b#� bdRW� Pb� cWT� d]XeTabXch#� cWT� V^eTa]\T]c� P]S� cWT� _aXePcT�
bTRc^a%� IWPaX]V� Tg_TaXT]RTb� X]� SXUUTaT]c�_Pacb� ^U�cWT� f^a[S�RP]�
R^[[PQ^aPcT� fXcW� cWT� STeT[^_\T]c� ^U� \^aT� \PcdaT� b^[dcX^]b%�
9XcXiT]� R^^_TaPcX^]� PRWXTeTS� fXcW� cWXb� ch_T� ^U�P__[XRPcX^]� X]�
P� b\Pac� RXch� RP]� QT� cWT� UXabcb� _a^c^ch_Tb� U^a� daQP]� \^ST[b
P]S�_dQ[XR�_^[XRXTb� QPbTS� ^]� SXVXcP[[h� QPbTS�_PacXRX_PcX^]� P]S�
X\_a^eT� cWT� RXchnb� R^[[PQ^aPcXeT� \P]PVT\T]c%
L??%� 76 > A B J ? 8 7 : 8 @ 8 A G
JWXb� f^aZ� Xb� _PacXP[[h� bd__^acTS� Qh� cWT� I\PacCTca^_^[Xb)#�
?DI?:;*� P]S� cWT� BPQ^aPc^ah� U^a� FdQ[XR� 8dSVTc� P]S� F^[XRXTb�
!BEFF"� ^U�cWT� FdQ[XR�CX]Xbcah� ^U�cWT� IcPcT� ^U�HX^� =aP]ST� S^�
D^acT� !CFHD"%
H8 9 8 E 8 A 6 8 F
L(M� 4%� 6N^NTYVa#� 6%� 7RY� 5\#� N[Q� C%� AVWXNZ]#� kFZN^`� PV`VR_� V[� Ra^\]R#l�
9V[XUHS� V M�[XIHU� ZLJOUVSVN_!� b\Y%� (/#� [\%� )#� ]]%� -,$/)#� )'((%
L)M� G%� ANZ� N[Q�G%� 4%� CN^Q\#� k6\[PR]`aNYVfV[T� _ZN^`� PV`e�cV`U� QVZR[_V\[_�
\S� `RPU[\Y\Te#� ]R\]YR#� N[Q� V[_`V`a`V\[_#l� V[� >XVJLLKPUNY� V M� ZOL� %&ZO�
HUU[HS� PUZLXUHZPVUHS� KPNPZHS� NV\LXUTLUZ� XLYLHXJO� JVUMLXLUJL.� KPNPZHS�
NV\LXUTLUZ� PUUV\HZPVU� PU� JOHSSLUNPUN� ZPTLY!� )'((#� ]]%� )/)$)0(%
L*M� ?%� 9R^^R``V#� 6%� JeZN[`#� @%� >R[QNYY#� ?%� KUN\#� 4%� Aa^`Ne#� ?%� 4ORYR^$�
7\^[R^#� @%� CN^XR^#� 7%� 5\[_NYY#� N[Q� 6%� 9^N_R^#� kDaN[`VSeV[T� _N^_$P\b$�
)� `^N[_ZV__V\[� _aTTR_`_� R]VQRZVP� P\[`^\Y� cV`U� QVTV`NY� P\[`NP`� `^NPV[T#l�
AJPLUJL!� b\Y%� *-/#� [\%� -+0(#� )')'%
L+M� 4%� 5%� 7N^#� 4%� ;%� ?\[R#� F%� KNU\\^#� 4%� 4%� >UN[#� N[Q� E%� A%� @V^#�
k4]]YVPNOVYV`e� \S� Z\OVYR� P\[`NP`� `^NPV[T� V[� SVTU`V[T� ]N[QRZVP� P\bVQ$�
(0!1� <__aR_#� PUNYYR[TR_� N[Q� _\Ya`V\[_%l� 802@� 2X_WZVS#� L>XPUZ�0XJO#!� b\Y%�
)')'#� ]%� +/+#� )')'%
L,M� A%�6NPU\#�9%�?\]R_#�8%�6NbNYPN[`R#�N[Q�<%� FN[`\_#� k4�_ZN^`�PV`e�V[V`VN`VbR1�
GUR� PN_R� \S�[N`NY#l� V[�&$%*�8444�8UZLXUHZPVUHS�ATHXZ�2PZPLY� 2VUMLXLUJL�
�8A2& #� <888#� )'(-#� ]]%� ($.%
L-M� E%� EN_XN^#� <%� FPUa[RZN[[#� E%� 5N^ON^#� >%� IVYPN[_#� =%� :^Ne#
C%� IR]NX\ZZN#� F%� >N]N#� 4%� Aaff\#� E%� :a]`N#� 4%� 5R^XR� LZ� HS#!� k4]]_�
T\[R� ^\TaR1� @NV[`NV[V[T� ]R^_\[NY� ]^VbNPe� V[� N[� R]VQRZVP#l� HXFP\�
WXLWXPUZ�HXFP\.&$$'#$,)*+!� )')'%
L.M� 4%� F\afN#� =%� CR^RV^N#� G%� 5N`V_`N#� 8%� 6NbNYPN[`R#� A%� 6NPU\#� 9%� ?\]R_#� N[Q�
4%� 4YZRVQN#� k4� TR\T^N]UVP$YNeR^RQ� QN`N� ZVQQYRcN^R� S\^� _ZN^`� PV`VR_#l�
V[�>XVJLLKPUNY�V M�ZOL�&(ZO�1XH`PSPHU�A_TWVYP[T�VU�;[SZPTLKPH�HUK�ZOL�
ELI!� )'(/#� ]]%� +(($+(+%
L/M� <[Y\P\#� k@N]N� O^N_VYRV^\� QN� P\bVQ$(0#l� U``]_1&&ZN]NO^N_VYRV^\QNP\bVQ%�
V[Y\P\%P\Z%O^&#� )')'%
L0M� C%� @\fa^#� E%� KU\[T#� N[Q� 4%� >^\YVX#� k<[� P\^\[NbV^a_� SVTU`#
PUV[N� TVbR_� PV`VfR[_�N� P\Y\^� P\QR#� cV`U� ^RQ� SYNT_#l� BOL� <L]�
GVXR� BPTLY#� LB[YV[RM%� 4bNVYNOYR1� U``]_1&&ccc%[e`VZR_%P\Z&)')'&'*&'(&�
Oa_V[R__&PUV[N$P\^\[NbV^a_$_a^bRVYYN[PR%U`ZY
L('M� 4]]YR� N[Q�:\\TYR#� kC^VbNPe$]^R_R^bV[T� P\[`NP`�`^NPV[T#l�0WWSL�]LIYPZL#�
LB[YV[RM%� 4bNVYNOYR1� U``]_1&&ccc%N]]YR%P\Z&P\bVQ(0&P\[`NP``^NPV[T
L((M� H>� AN`V\[NY� ;RNY`U� FR^bVPR#� k6\^\[NbV^a_� P\bVQ$(0!� V[P^RN_R�
V[� a_R� \S� [U_� QVTV`NY� `RPU#l� <7A%� LB[YV[RM%� 4bNVYNOYR1� U``]_1�
&&QVTV`NY%[U_%aX&P\^\[NbV^a_&[U_$QVTV`NY$`RPU$N[NYe`VP_
L()M� :\bR^[ZR[`� \S� <[QVN#� k4N^\TeN� _R`a� Z\OVYR� N]]#l� ;_6V\#� LB[YV[RM%�
4bNVYNOYR1� U``]_1&&ccc%ZeT\b%V[&NN^\TeN$_R`a$N]]&
L(*M� @NZON�?NO_#� k7eP\bVQ#l� ELIYPZL#� LB[YV[RM%� 4bNVYNOYR1� U``]_1&&QeP\bVQ%�
P\Z%O^&
)U``]_1&&_ZN^`ZR`^\]\YV_%VZQ%aS^[%O^&
*U``]_1&&V[_VQR%VZQ%aS^[%O^&
Authorized licensed use limited to: IEEE Xplore. Downloaded on March 04,2021 at 13:22:49 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.